A Look At The Patchwork Pitching Staff

I have the unfortunate job of informing you, the Phillies fan, that there’s a good chance your 2008 Phillies will show up at Citizens Bank Park to play the Washington Nationals March 31 with … with … Shane Youman.

Or someone like that.

It seems the Phils have a hard time getting to a good 25-man roster. Last year, they had about 21 of 25. This year, it’s probably more like … well, it’s 21 again.

Here is the heavy 21 (if they all make it out alive): Ruiz, Coste, Howard, Utley, Dobbs, Helms, Rollins, Bruntlett, Burrell, Victorino, Jenkins, Werth, Taguchi, Hamels, Myers, Kendrick, Moyer, Lidge, Gordon, Romero, Madson.

That means four spots are up for grabs, and look — all the spots are pitching spots! How not obvious! Of course, these spots could be filled some other way between now and March 31, but for the sake of prediction, I’m going to run through the candidates for the final four right now. All these pitchers are going to Spring Training:

Joe Bisenius: The 25-year-old righty reliever walked two and gave up two hits with the Phillies in 2007. He also struck out three. He struggled in Ottawa, but seems ripe for the MLB call. I’d take my chances on him as a 6th inning guy, easing him into the ‘pen rotation if he succeeds.

Travis Blackley: At 25, the Rule V pick will either get on the club or leave the organization. Plus, he’d have to stay on board all year if the Phils would want to keep him. The Phils don’t necessarily need a left-handed starter, so he would need a lights-out Clearwater stint to even be considered.

Carlos Carrasco: The No. 1 prospect projects somewhere between a No. 2 and 3 starter, but don’t expect him to be that guy in March. He struggled a little when joining Reading, so a few more games in AA won’t hurt. I’d like to see him in limited September action in Philadelphia, ready for a call-up around mid-2009.

Fabio Castro: The young lefty was fast-tracked to the Majors, and 2007 showed to be a result of that fast-tracking, as he stumbled a bit. He’s a hell of a strikeout pitcher (32 K in 44 MLB innings, better in the Minors), so he should have an inside track at the LOOGY spot. With a strong spring, I wouldn’t mind seeing him there in April.

Ron Chiavacci: The career Minor Leaguer was impressive in AAA Toledo last year (12-6, 3.39 ERA, 126 K), but at 30, he would need a hell of a Spring to be considered the fifth starter over the Major League vet Adam Eaton. He could slip on the club as the mop-up reliever, and in that race, he should be considered a top challenger.

Clay Condrey: He isn’t a bad mop-up guy, but then again, mop-up guys are supposed to be kind of bad, and to be “not bad” at it isn’t quite cutting it overall, now is it? Last year he was a frequent flier on Air Canada, notching 27 innings for Philly and Ottawa and putting up a 5.00+ ERA with the big club. I’d like a new direction at mop-up man, but consider Condrey the slight favorite, as he’s the incumbent.

Vic Darensbourg: Who now? Picture Condrey, but five years older. Darensbourg was good with Toledo last year (6-2, 1.72 ERA, 42 K), but how good can a career frequent flier be at 37? He could prove valuable as a left-handed alternative to Condrey, but as Vic is a non-roster invitee, I can’t picture the Vic-House in pinstripes to start the year.

Chad Durbin: Making his Major League debut in 1998, Durbin isn’t a stranger to this game. He’s spent every year since then on a Major League 25-man roster at some point; last year, he spent the whole year with Detroit, notching a 4.72 ERA. That makes him the fifth best pitcher on the 2007 Phillies (I didn’t research that, but I bet I’m really close). He’ll be Eaton’s main competition, and could easily grab the mop-up role if Eaton is healthy and good enough to go. I’d pencil him onto my roster.

JD Durbin: If this guy can start 10 games for the division champion Phillies, anything is possible. Durbin is an outside candidate for the mop-up role, as his 5.15 ERA and relatively cheap price will make him a tough draw for fifth starter. At 26, he’s still just young enough to spend the beginning of the year in Allentown without denting his growth. Of course, he may be finished growing. I say he spends the majority of 2008 as an Iron Pig.

Adam Eaton: Because he’s worth $8MM next year, Eaton is the favorite for fifth starter. He’ll likely have a spot on the big club — if he’s healthy. As of right now, nobody’s sure. He’ll need to show he’s healthy both physically and mentally to prove he’s worth the ball every five days. If he’s the least bit unhealthy, I DL the guy until he’s ready.

John Ennis: Colorado-born John Wayne Ennis (yes, that’s right) had a small light and sweet with the Phils last year, and if we’re lucky, that’s what he won’t have this year. He pitched well last year in Ottawa, but that’s where he fits — Ennis seems destined to be a career AAA starter. He’s just not good enough; I’d rather have Condrey or Darensbourg, to be honest.

Anderson Garcia: The other Andy Garcia, at 27, is a lot like Ennis, although his numbers in AAA are worse. This makes Garcia an unattractive option for the March 31 opener. Let’s move on.

JA Happ: With one rough breaking-in start against the Mets under his belt, Happ remains the prospect closest to smelling Big League grass for good. But with his latest injury concerns and spotty play in AAA, I can’t see Happ as completely ready to start the year with the Phillies. He’s joining Jason Jaramillo and Bisenius in Rookie Development Camp, so that’s a small sign he’s on the short list of guys jumping up immediately. I’d like to see him, with success, joining the club as a trial mop-up guy in May or June.

Lincoln Holdzkom: The former Red Sox prospect was gobbled up by the Phils in the Rule V, and while he has more promise than Blackley, it would a stretch to assume he’ll be on the big-league roster all season, avoiding release. Can you stash a guy like Holdzkom as the 25th man? Only if he’s worthy of being the sixth inning guy; he’ll compete heavy with Bisenius.

Gary Knotts: Only some past Major League experience and a strong 21 innings in Reading last year has him in Spring Training this year. To me, he’s one of the last guys to be considered for an open spot.

Scott Mathieson: A real wild card, Mathieson has recovered from Tommy John surgery and is considered a favorite for one of the final four spots. I agree, and I think he should be given the best chance to play sixth inning guy. The 24-year-old has been talked about as a closer candidate; while I don’t know if he has closer stuff, he’s definitely a possibility to become the everyday setup man by August (I forsee another Gordon breakdown).

Just check out these numbers from his 2006 stint with the Phils (37.1 IP):

1st PA against batter: 75 PA, .238 AVG, .283 OBP, .286 SLG, 14 K

2nd PA against batter: 70 PA, .377 AVG, .441 OBP, .754 SLG, 11 K

What a difference, huh? Mathieson seems poised to be a top-of-the-line setup guy, and in 2008, the role of Madson’s doppleganger will work just fine.

Brian Mazone: The former Independent League star has made a nice transition to the Minors (and Japan), but at 31, can he sustain a role in the Majors? As nice as his story could be, I can’t see him up with the big club, especially as a non-roster invitee.

Joshua Outman: One of the club’s top prospects, Outman is right below Happ in the organizational depth chart, since he’s without the Major League experience. The 23-year-old is really in the same boat as Carrasco, having some transition troubles in Reading. He’s been talked about as a possibility for Allentown to start 2008, but I’d almost rather see him start a few games in AA before moving up. A September call-up for good is possible, as well, but for the opening day roster, he’s not quite ready yet.

Francisco Rosario: Though I’m not a fan of his mugshot, he wasn’t totally bad last year. An 8.54 K/9 is good, though his 5.47 ERA isn’t. The righty should be battling with Bisenius and Mathieson for a spot, but he’s fighting a tough battle.

Joe Savery: The first-round pick from last year isn’t ready for a stint in the majors; his time in Clearwater is merely for some tuning. Expect him at the earliest in mid-2009.

Shane Youman: Sub-par Shane. He had a good season with Pittsburgh in 2006, then stumbled last year without a clear-cut role. He’ll be tried out as a LOOGY with the Phillies, challenging Castro and Zagurski. He may be the early favorite because of his veteran status. I’d be careful.

Mike Zagurski: He munched through the Minors last year, and though that might seem impressive, he’s 25 this year, which puts him closer to being a has-been. Castro may have the upper end because of his potential, but if Zagurski can keep his hit totals down in the Spring, he could win out for the LOOGY job.

So if everyone performs at the same level during the Spring, let’s say (which will never happen, but we need a variable), who are the four that win my spots?

Fifth starter
1. Adam Eaton. If — and only if — he’s healthy.
2. Chad Durbin.
3. JD Durbin.

Mop-up reliever
1. Chad Durbin. He could prove to be good in spot starts.
2. Clay Condrey.
3. Ron Chiavacci.

Right-handed sixth inning option
1. Scott Mathieson. Set-up man of the future.
2. Joe Bisenius.
3. Francisco Rosario.

Left-handed one-out guy
1. Fabio Castro. Has potential to be a good set-up man.
2. Mike Zagurski.
3. Shane Youman.

Hamels/Myers/Kendrick/Moyer/Eaton … Lidge/Gordon/Romero/Madson/Mathieson/Castro/Durbin. Is this a good group? You be the judge.

Click to comment


  1. Rodney King

    January 8, 2008 at 10:51 am

    Can’t we all just get a pitcher?

  2. xfactor

    January 8, 2008 at 12:20 pm

    Thanks for the rundown. For the most part I think you’re spot-on. But I do take issue with this sentence: “Because he’s worth $8MM next year, Eaton is the favorite for fifth starter.”

    In economic terms, Eaton is a ‘sunk cost’, which means he’ll get that money whether he pitches or not. In essence, his salary should have no bearing whatsoever on his playing time. Now, you could argue that the Phillies Brass don’t see it that way, but it doesn’t change the flaw in that line of reasoning.

    You can’t push Eaton to ‘earn’ his contract. He earned it the day he signed. The smart course of action is to let the best man win the spot in the rotation regardless of salary. Otherwise, you run the risk of turning a financial loss into a statistical one.

    Having said that, I still think Eaton could rebound and have a good season. But he should have to earn playing time on the field in the Bank, not in line at the bank.

  3. Tim Malcolm

    January 8, 2008 at 12:31 pm

    xfactor: You’re right on that — I think I simplified Eaton in my writing. In my logic, he makes $8MM because of his past performance, the hopes of Phillies brass of him going into the 2007 season and a misjudgement of the market last year.

    So really, because he is still figured to be a back-rotation starter capable of throwing 200 IP, and because the Phils wouldn’t necessarily want to tank $8MM on lost seasons, I could see him as the favorite for No. 5 as of today.

    But you’re absolutely right. He doesn’t deserve the favoritism for being an $8MM man. May the best man win — however, remember, best man has to be considered with at least a glance of potential, and out of the starter candidates, Eaton still has the most potential.

  4. Dave Kingman

    January 8, 2008 at 1:11 pm

    Happ is a lefty.

  5. Tim Malcolm

    January 8, 2008 at 1:25 pm

    Yeah, I knew that. Fixed.

  6. Ryan

    January 9, 2008 at 3:04 pm

    the phils definitely need to add a quality lefty in the pen.

  7. Gavin

    January 9, 2008 at 7:46 pm

    that pen makes me run for the john.

  8. RUDY

    January 10, 2008 at 4:24 pm


    Have Lidge Setting Up Myers. Instead of Gordon setting up Lidge.

    Did we forget that Myers stinks as a starter but was tremendous in the bullpen.

    Lets sign a guy with Myers kind of starting stats 4.50ERA + add Myers back to the closer rule.

  9. The A Team

    January 11, 2008 at 1:35 pm

    Rudy, perhaps you didn’t notice Myers’ 3.72 and 3.91 ERA’s in ’05 and ’06 respectively or his 413.1 IP and 397 K over the same 2 year period. Perhaps you also missed his 1.21 and 1.30 WHIPs over those seasons. In any case, to suggest that Myers stinks as a starter is simply inane. It is a supreme waste to put Myers in the closers role where he gives us 60 IP rather than 200 IP.

    The starting rotation is and always has been more important than the bullpens. If we could sign a guy with Myers ability, both would remain in the rotation and Lidge would still be closing.

    On a side note, the pen will work out as it did last year. Relief pitchers are fickle creatures, you can always find a guy who’ll be a ‘hot hand’ for you with relative ease (i.e. Romero and Mesa last year or Geary in ’06). The real challenge is finding reliable guys you can count on year after year.

  10. GoPhils

    January 13, 2008 at 12:28 pm

    Amen, A Team. Myers has already had success as a big league starter, and he’s just coming into what should be his prime years. A much bigger problem is counting on Kendrick as a No. 3. He had a great year last year and showed tremendous heart. But his stuff, his pedigree and his secondary stats all suggest he’s going to have a tough time duplicating his success. I’ll be surprised if we’re still talking about him as the No. 3 after the all star break and won’t be surprised if the much-reviled Adam Eaton puts up a better year.

  11. alexbookhyip

    April 2, 2008 at 7:28 pm

    I have carried out large research and collected the most interesting
    sites about online investment in the Internet

    I choose only update and developing ones and collected them in the same place.
    They are accessible for everybody.
    I offer you to acquaint with them ( online investing bookmak )
    If somebody can supplement my list please publish here your research or bookmark

    PS I am sorry if my message out of forum topic or it`s not interesting to community.

  12. alexbookmin

    April 3, 2008 at 12:16 pm

    I have carried out large work and collected the most interesting
    sites about online business in the Internet

    I choose only update and developing ones and collected them in the same place.
    They are accessible for everybody.
    I offer you to acquaint with them ( online investing bookmak )
    If somebody can supplement my list please publish here your research or bookmark

    PS I am sorry if my message out of forum topic or it`s not interesting to community.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2016
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top