Manuel On Keeping In Hamels: “I Liked Him” – Phillies Nation

Manuel On Keeping In Hamels: “I Liked Him”

Charlie Manuel told reporters after the game why he went with Cole Hamels in the eighth inning last night. (Hamels gave up the winning home run to Prince Fielder in the Phils’ 5-4 loss.)

“When [Braun] hit the double, I definitely was going to leave him in there on Fielder. Fielder had a good at-bat. He fouled off some pitches, and he got him. But at the same time, I liked [Hamels], I still liked him in the game. I liked him there, and I wanted him to stay there.”

Because Manuel “liked” Hamels is kind of a bland excuse, although it’s likely true. Still, JC Romero was available, as was Tom Gordon, who likely would’ve faced the bottom of the Brewers’ order in the ninth. Hindisight is 20/20 in this situation — you can’t completely fault Manuel for sticking with his ace — his best pitcher — in a high-pressure situation, but Romero was re-signed to be the main defuser of high-pressure situations, especially against left-handed hitters. Getting Fielder out, then bringing in Chad Durbin to face the righties would’ve been fine.

It’s also important to note this is early in the season, probably too early to be shuttling your starters out deep into questionable situations. Hamels had his crack at Braun and he failed. As much as it’s nice to give Hamels confidence, it means more to win the game. The irony, of course, is that Tuesday night giving Brett Myers confidence to stay in against the Rockies was priority one, and he also blew up in his final inning. The difference there was the Phils weren’t in the lead then.

Bottom line: Eighth inning, one-run lead, starter has over 100 pitches. First hitter strikes an easy double with no outs. Time to go to your pen. If it’s August I may have something different to say.

Click to comment


  1. MS

    April 24, 2008 at 11:20 am

    I do disagree with the Hamels decision – but admit it is a little MMQB. As much as Charlie was responsible for the Tuesday win (great pinch hit decisions), he is at fault for last night’s loss.

    but my real issue is with the Burrell substitution. Can someone who is for the late-inning defensive substitution please help me understand why this is a good thing? i really think he needs to stay in there 9 innings every game.

  2. The Big Irish

    April 27, 2008 at 10:46 am

    Yeah, Charlie, we ALL like Hamels. But you left him in too long, pal. When you make a mistake, it is a strength to admit it and not let it happen again. Sheesh.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2016
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top