The 2008 Phandom 25: What A Comeback – Phillies Nation
2008 Phandom 25

The 2008 Phandom 25: What A Comeback

Last year I wrote a series of posts chronicling 2007’s 20 greatest moments in Phillies Phandom. Each game had a special “wow” factor, whether it was an insane comeback, an awesome feat or a trademark moment. And each game was a Phillies win, of course.

For this year, clearly, you know the top moment. But ranking the rest was very difficult. Do I rank the NLCS second just because? Is the NL East clinching victory as important as other postseason moments? I used some heavy discretion, but I believe I came up with a pretty solid list.

Each moment has an attached video link, if you’d like to go back and reminisce.

Like the 100 Greatest Phillies countdown, I’ll be posting one per day. I swear, you won’t get any more countdowns this offseason.


7. Game of the year.
August 26, 2008

One-hundred and seventy-six games. Fourteen of them in do-or-die playoff situations. Four incredible wins in the World Series. But one game was more thrilling than all of them.

August 26, 2008. The day the Phillies-Mets rivalry became, proof-positive, the best rivalry in baseball.

It was a long Tuesday night. It started a little after 7 p.m., as Jose Reyes took out his 4-iron and teed off a lining triple against Jamie Moyer. A few singles and some wild pitching later, and the Mets had staked a 2-0 lead in the first. It was typical for the Metropolitians to do this — they were peaking at this point, with Reyes hitting the bags in the first and scoring runs like nothing else mattered. Though Rollins responded in the bottom with a leadoff double, the heavy hitters failed.

The Mets went back to work off Moyer. Damion Easley homered to make it 3-0. And in the third, Carlos Beltran and David Wright set up the rejuvenated Fernando Tatis. One swing later, and the Mets had a 6-0 lead. Goodbye, Jamie; goodbye, game.

danny: The Mets are such a better team than us except for their bullpen. Hell, if their bullpen wasn’t a joke, and ours wasnt having career years all around, we’re down like 5-10 games to them.

Griffin: to be fair, we weren’t winning that game anyway. oh well, Kendrick vs. Johan tomorrow!! ugh.

David, the Mets fan from Queens: Believe it or not, I am still not confident with a six-run lead when our bullpen will pitch AT LEAST three innings tonight. Do you hear me, my fellow Mets fans?

Now down 7-0, the Phils decided to start hitting Martinez. It started slowly — Shane Victorino reached on fielder’s choice, stole second, moved to third on a classic Jayson Werth blooper, then scored on a Pedro Feliz sacrifice fly. 7-1.

With Clay Condrey settling in, the Phils went back to work in the fifth. And it started with Condrey.

The mop-up righty hammered a double to start the fifth. Yes, a double. That brought up Rollins, looking to spark something — and he did. Boom, a shot to right, and it was 7-3. Things were starting to pick up.

Richie Allen: I told you..I told you..we are gonna win today…I guarantee it

Chase Utley walked, as Martinez started to wither. Though Pedro got a slumping Burrell to strike out, Ryan Howard wasn’t going down as easy. He cranked an opposite-field blast — his league-leading 35th — to make it 7-5. Now it was a game, setting up a new matchup: The best bullpen in the National League vs. the most troubled relief corps.

The Phillies turned to new acquisition Scott Eyre, who proved his worth with a stellar 1.2 innings. The Mets went with Brian Stokes, who slung a strong two frames. But in the eighth, Mets manager Jerry Manuel decided to turn to his veterans, men who the Phillies just knew how to hit.

First, Duaner Sanchez. Goggles lasted one out, until a Carlos Ruiz single lifted him. In came Pedro Feliciano, who surrendered a single by pinch-hitting Chris Coste (remember, this is the eighth). A Rollins single (his fifth hit in five tries) brought home Ruiz. 7-6. Joe Smith finally finished it, securing a one-run lead with new closer Luis Ayala coming on board.

But before the Phils could attempt to tie the game, they had to salvage the top of the ninth. One man remained on the bench: Eric Bruntlett. But Charlie Manuel didn’t want to waste Bruntlett’s bat. At the time, we all wondered, “Why? Who cares?” but clearly, Manuel knew better. Instead of bringing in Bruntlett, he kept Coste as catcher and moved Ruiz to third base. A move like that makes it a once-in-a-lifetime game.

The move paid off in spades. Ruiz saw nothing in the ninth, as Brad Lidge recorded a 1-2-3 frame. And in the bottom, finally, Bruntlett got his chance.

It didn’t come easy. A Howard flyout and Burrell groundout put the Phils against the wall. Up stepped Werth, who kept it alive with a single. That brought up the pitcher’s spot, and Manuel made his move to Bruntlett.

“Line drive to right center!”

I didn’t think it. You didn’t think it. Nobody thought it. Sure, I said, “He’d need a double here, but a good double. But Bruntlett?” but I didn’t really think it. How could I? And yet, Bruntlett stroked a perfectly-placed double, Werth got the green light, and Easley’s throw — while very good — was a touch off for Brian Schnieder. Tie game. 7-7.

J-Man: Definitly one of the best games i’ve seen in awhile…Well here comes Madson to blow it.

Then came extra innings. While Ryan Madson extinguished the Mets easily, the Phils threatened against Aaron Heilman, but couldn’t deliver. Rollins had a chance, Howard had a chance, Burrell had a chance. But nothing.

Until the 13th. After Manuel exhausted his bullpen, the Mets had Scott Schoeneweis. And Victorino greeted him with a smoked liner into right field. Landing on third, Vic set up the Phils for a big win. The Mets countered by walking the bases loaded. And with nobody left on the bench to pinch hit, Manuel turned to pitcher Brett Myers.

Call it a precursor to his gigantic at bat against CC Sabathia in the division series, because Myers tapped into his big-game persona, heroically standing in as if he wanted to bash one out of the park. Instead, he took pitch after pitch, almost … almost … working a game-winning walk. While he struck out, it riled the crowd and roughed the Mets.

Evan: That was the worst pitching/at bat I’ve ever seen in major league ball.

Up stepped Coste, who despite entering in the eighth, had three hits in his stat line. Assuredly, Coste locked in and smoked a ball deep into center field. No need to be dramatic — the distance itself secured the winning run. 8-7 final. Phillies win. Exhausting, exhilirating, it was the best win of the season, the best game of the season. It featured big offense, clutch hitting, fine pitching, tense moments, heated fan reactions, great defense, awesome tactical moves, big payoffs. Simply put, it’s why we watch and love the game.

And it’s why this rivarly is the best there is.

The video: Coste ends it



  1. T Marty

    January 18, 2009 at 10:19 am

    i was at that game, and remember when it was 7-0 my wife and i were contemplating leaving, but we hung in there, and boy did it pay off, by the end it felt like a play off game. So exciting.

    Somebody told me some other Philly team has a big game today, but i’m still reeling in the glory that was the 2008 baseball season.

  2. Griffin

    January 18, 2009 at 10:59 am

    That August 26th game was a microcosm of the entire NL East race. Great game, great team.

  3. Jim

    January 18, 2009 at 11:01 am

    Cant nessecarily say I agree with that metaphor griffin; seeing as the phils were in first place almsot everyday from the end of april until the allstar break and the mets were flirting with .500 line until the all star break as well and then we switched back and forth for a few weeks.

  4. Nationals#1

    January 18, 2009 at 11:05 am

    I went to this game with my friend who’s a mets fan, and we were this close to buying tickets to the wednesday night game. best decision i’ve ever made, as this was not only the best baseball game that i ever went to, but the best baseball game i’ve ever seen. with the phils down 7 – 0, i was looking pretty bummed and my friend turned to me and said “i’ve seen them blow 7 run leads before”

  5. Griffin

    January 18, 2009 at 11:15 am

    Jim, I meant that the Mets bullpen stunk and that the Phillies never quit and came from behind to win the game (and the division in September).

  6. Amanda

    January 18, 2009 at 12:13 pm

    I was there!! Best game I’ve ever been to. It was awesome! 7-0, and the Mets fans around us were all confident cheering. Then as the game went on, they headed to the exits.

  7. Howard

    January 18, 2009 at 12:14 pm

    I was at this game as well. My best friend scored some tickets to the HOF club at CBP, and by the 2nd inning started asking the question “Do we stay or do we go? We hung back, and told him that hopefully we can start chipping at the lead. The key thing that he said to me, “Anything is possible with this team.” I told him OK, let’s stay until the 7th inning. Glad we did. On the way home, he was headed back down to Cape May, and I was heading back to Frederick, MD (yes, I got in at 3:30AM and was at work at 11 AM with much appreciation extended to my new boss), I called him on the cell and told him this was THE signature game for the regular season. Everyone is welcome to discuss, but it boiled down to one thing that stayed true with this team – It takes a TEAM to win. It wasn’t the greatest as far as stats go, but in my opinion this was the benchmark game as it defined the rest of the season.

  8. nate

    January 18, 2009 at 12:34 pm

    was a work at a news station in New York with some mets fans…. and it was during one of the national political conventions. i was kind of just doing a support job so i was paying more attention to the game, and when they won it, the mets fans were cursing and i was happy, and we got yelled at by the show producer for being loud. the thing is that i remember being at the same place when the phils almost came back from like 10 runs down against the mets in what i think was a brett myers start. i watched sportscenter over and over the next day.

  9. nate

    January 18, 2009 at 12:37 pm

    there it is… adam eaton start against the mets on july 7th. 10-9 final.

  10. clktwr14

    January 18, 2009 at 1:47 pm

    I remember this game started to watch on TV, got disgusted, turn off the TV,Wheels makes me sick, turn the radio on, to listen to Scott and LA, but after they started to comeback had to turn the Tv back to finish watching this game, almost jump through my ceiling, as Coste hit that incredible single over the head of a drawn in Beltran.

  11. BrewTownPhilsPhan

    January 18, 2009 at 3:16 pm

    Well written, Tim. I remember that game, and this got my heart pumping all over again. That was the night I thought, “This team could really do something in the postseason!”

  12. J cole

    January 20, 2009 at 12:47 am

    I forgot how good of a game this one was.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2016
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top