Non-Tendered Targets – Phillies Nation

Non-Tendered Targets

Lannan is now available. Would you like to see him in Phillies' pinstripes?

Yesterday, we learned the Phillies did not tender a contract to outfielder Nate Schierholtz. With that move, the Phillies sit at 37 players on their 40-man roster and now have some wiggle-room to address their needs at third base, center field, and pitching.

If you’ve read my posts before, I love talking about non-tenders, non-roster invitees, and other roster minutia. I also love shopping at discount stores for bargains and then comparing my shopping experiences to baseball transactions. Monitoring the non-tender wire helps give me that fix. Here are players other teams non-tendered that would be worth a Minor League contract and an invite to Spring Training.

Starting Pitching

John Lannan

Wow – have the Nationals built up that good of a quality rotation that they’re letting Lannan walk? While Phillies fans remember Lannan as the guy who broke Utley’s hand midway through his MVP run of 2007, and maybe cost the Phillies the 2007 World Series, Lannan has been a consistent workhorse, whose career ERA+ is a plenty good 103. Lannan got squeezed out of the Nats rotation just a year after putting up a 3.70 ERA and is only 27. If you’re not comfortable with Vance Worley, Kyle Kendrick, or Tyler Cloyd, this is the bargain you look at first.

Juan Oramas

Oramas spent six seasons in the Padres system after signing as a teenage free agent out of Mexico. Oramas was on the fast track to reaching the Majors as a starter but has been slowed by bone spurs as recently as August 2012. Oramas is just 5’10 but drew comparisons to Fernando Valenzuela for his use of breaking pitches and his non-reliance on power. Oramas would be my one, no-doubt-about-it project signing. Oramas is only 22 and already has pitched in Triple-A – he should be ready to go after healing from bone spurs and this would be quite the nice, under-the-radar pick up on a Minor League deal. It is unknown which role Oramas would settle into as he has been more of a swing-man than not during his Minor League career.

Relief Pitching

Rafael Perez

Perez was non-tendered by the Cleveland Indians yesterday after a season where he pitched in just eight games due to a strained lat. In 329 career Major League innings, Perez has 268 Ks and a 3.64 ERA, pitching only for the Indians in the American League. Since 2010, Perez relied heavily on his mid-80s slider, which is his only truly plus pitch. Perez has a record of being an innings eater, appearing in more than 50 games in four out of the last five seasons and 70 games in three of those. According to FanGraphs, last season was the only year that Perez did not provide positive value to the Indians – in a small sample last year, Perez saw a sharp increase in fly balls and a sharp decrease in ground balls. If Perez has a healthy lat, a working slider and pitches close to his 54.5% GB%, he would be worth a long look for Philadelphia.

Peter Moylan

Can you believe Moylan is already 33? Time flies, right? Listen, Moylan is a little older but has a career 2.59 ERA and looked sharp (1.80 ERA in 5 IP) in his return from injury last year. This is a flyer you take every time if you can. If the Phillies eliminate some of the bullpen logjam by trading away some of their young pieces, I would look to refill the stockpile with a guy like Moylan, who relies on a low 90s fastball, high 80s slider combo to induce a lot of ground balls.

Third Base

Mark Reynolds

Admittedly, the list of capable third baseman who were non-tendered is a little thin and adding a guy who has struck out over 200 times in a season three times is often less than desirable, however Reynolds can mash, mash, and mash. Did I mention he can hit for power? Reynolds has a very nice career .475 SLG%, which is even crazier when you compare it to his .235 BA and find out that he has a career .240 ISO. Reynolds barely makes this list, as he fits the Phillies right-handed power needs, but also barely plays third base any more. Reynolds unfortunately won’t come cheap either but if the Phillies are serious about adding power, and punting things like batting average and defense, they should at least call Reynolds.


Brandon Snyder

When compiling this list, I tried to avoid listing players I thought would be simply nice to invite to camp and include only players that I thought could contribute on Day 1 and make the team. Hence, no Ryan Sweeney on this list. Despite how much I like him in a bench role, the Phillies don’t have a bench role to give. Snyder is my one guilty pleasure in this year’s crop of non-tenders. Snyder was the Orioles’ first round pick in 2005 and just turned 26. He’s spent only parts of three seasons in the Big Leagues but is: 1. right handed, 2. powerful, 3. an outfielder, and 4. can fake catcher and third base if needed. Snyder reminds me a lot of another former Orioles first-round pick, Jayson Werth, but without the speed. In the minors, Snyder walked a lot and struck out very little – he could be a diamond in the rough for whoever ends up signing him. I’m not sure the Phillies would take a chance on a project with the possibility of the projects that are Darin Ruf and Domonic Brown manning the corners.

Andres Torres

If the Phillies can’t get Angel Pagan, why not settle for the player he was traded for? Ok, bad example but Torres has some value, particularly on a cheap deal and in the event they swing and miss acquiring any center fielders. Torres hit .230/.327/.337 and won’t get embarrassed playing center field. Torres should be Plan C or D.

Wild Card

Geovany Soto

With the unfortunate suspension of Chooch, the Phillies enter 2013 with Erik Kratz as their likely starting catcher. If Soto is cheap, read: as close to the league minimum as possible, he would be a nice target to bring to camp. But, much like Reynolds, enough other teams are interested in Soto that a bargain is probably not to be had here. Since winning the NL Rookie of the Year in 2008, Soto’s numbers have tail-spinned downward but turns only 30 next season and would be worth a gamble for team who needs a starter and doesn’t have any young talent to bring up.

Players to Avoid

Not every deal is a good one just because it is cheap. Here are a few of the non-tenders I would avoid that look like bargains on the surface: Jaye Chapman, Jesus Flores, Ben Francisco, Tom Gorzalanny, Jair Jurrjens, Ian Stewart, Ryan Sweeney

Click to comment


  1. Lefty

    December 1, 2012 at 10:36 am

    I like Lannan, but he will be looking for a guaranteed spot in a rotation somewhere after what happened to him last year. (spending most of the season in the minors to serve as Strasburg’s replacement when his innings were up) Would Kendrick accept a long man designation? Maybe.

    Peter Moylan doesn’t seem old because he didn’t get to the majors until he was 27. Yeah I’d take a flyer there on a non guaranteed deal pending health. Soto might be worth a look for the first month too.

  2. Jay Floyd

    December 1, 2012 at 10:48 am

    Everyone sweated the K’s and batting average, when it came to Upton, so I am sure fans and media types would feel more strongly toward Reynolds in that regard.

    On Reynolds- low yearly batting avg., .807 career OPS (upgrade from Polanco’s .747 career OPS), big K’s approaching 200 in a full season, .928 career fielding % at 3rd (big downgrade from Polanco’s .983), .146 hitter in 13 postseason games. All of that is not appealing, but for some reason I wouldn’t hate it if the Phils got him at a bargain price on a short deal. I have confidence in the farm system to fill this void in the coming 1-3 years.

  3. frank

    December 1, 2012 at 11:48 am

    Just wondering – why not Jesus flores.

  4. hk

    December 1, 2012 at 11:50 am

    I would not be so quick to dismiss Ryan Sweeney. If the team wants to go cheap in CF and sign a corner OF like Hamilton or Swisher, a Sweeney / Mayberry Jr. platoon in CF could work. Combined in a strict platoon, Sweeney and JMJ could give them decent defense and an OPS of ~.800.

    • EricL

      December 1, 2012 at 12:27 pm

      I think that might be a productive solution to CF, but I don’t see it happening due to the non-tendering of Schierholtz. If the Phillies were looking to go with a platoon-style OF, I don’t see them cutting him, as he’s good defensively and hits RHP very well, a good complement to Mayberry.

  5. Don M

    December 3, 2012 at 9:48 am

    Reynolds vs LHP is very good matchup … not sure what his cost would be, but he’d be a good play in a power spot vs LHP if he could be signed for a cheap deal

    • Ken Bland

      December 3, 2012 at 12:26 pm

      I dunno, Don, he’s certainly better. Whether he makes for a very good matchup, guess it depends on your criteria or slant. I was curious how much his propensity for striking out came into play against lefties, and it is as you’d expect,…well, here are some digits, anyone reading can pass their own judgement…

      career V righties 2538 PA 854 K’s 34% OPS .319

      career V lefties 905 PA 268 K’s 30% OPS .367

      Last year didn’t seem to establish anoverall trend of an improving player.

      I’m not really making a point here. I just read your thought, and was curious if maybe a tremendous percentage of his massive K work came against righties. Doesn’t appear to be the case.

    • schmenkman

      December 3, 2012 at 1:29 pm

      To clarify, what’s shown above is on-base percentage (OBP).

      career OPS vs. righties: .789
      career OPS vs. lefties: .857

      Interestingly, the last two years he has actually hit better against RHPs (a bit less on-base, but much more power):

      2011-12 vs. righties .. .222/.324/.473 (.797 OPS)
      2011-12 vs. lefties ….. .217/.339/.414 (.753 OPS)

      • Ken Bland

        December 3, 2012 at 1:41 pm

        lol, that better be his OBP. .300 OPS isn’t too good. Good catch.

  6. Don M

    December 3, 2012 at 12:39 pm

    He strikes out a ton…. but he gets on base vs LHP.. and hits them harder than he does RHP…

    I’d call him a great example of “IF THE PRICE IS RIGHT” ……

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2016
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top