A’s Explode for 12 Runs Behind Cochrane’s Monster Game – Phillies Nation

A’s Explode for 12 Runs Behind Cochrane’s Monster Game

The Philadelphia A’s took Game 3 of the Philly Dream Series over the Phillies by a score of 12-4. They were led by Mickey Cochrane’s explosive night at the plate in which he hit for the cycle and drove in five runs. The Phillies still lead the series by a count of 2 games to 1.


Cochrane hit for the cycle.

The remarkable thing about Mickey Cochrane is that, by all accounts, he was a better football player than baseball player in high school. But since there was money to be made in baseball in the early 1920s, and not in football, he decided to play professionally with a leather glove instead of a leather ball. On this day, all of North Philadelphia is thankful.

His nifty night began in the top of the first. After a Mule Haas double, Mick (who, ironically, is of Scottish ancestry) singled into right center to bring the Mule home. It continued in the 3rd, as Cochrane opened the frame by delivering a ground rule double over the center field wall. Al Simmons would bring him home with a single a few moments later.

In the 4th, the floodgates opened. After Moyer hit Max Bishop with a pitch, and Mule Haas cracked another double, up stepped Cochrane. He delivered a shot into the right center gap that had more speed behind it than Werth and Victorino accounted for. It rolled to the wall, then took an awkward bounce off the wall towards center, and by the time Victorino wrangled it with his mitt and sent it back to the infield, Cochrane was standing on third. (Catchers don’t typically hit many triples, but Mickey is the exception. His 64 career triples were the most of any 20th century catcher in the Hall of Fame.) His three-bagger gave the A’s a 6-2 lead. That lead was stretched to 7-2 when Al Simmons sent him home a few minutes later with a single. Not long after, third baseman Jimmy Dykes hit a moonshot over the right field wall, and the rout was on.


Werth watches Cochrane’s homer disappear into the crowd.

But Mickey wasn’t done. In the 5th, Cochrane stepped up with old Eddie Collins standing on third. Chad Durbin tried to sneak a fastball past him. Bad move. Cochrane laced a shot into right. Werth turned and waited for it to bounce off the wall. It never did. It just grazed the metal fence above a Red Cross sign and hurtled into the seats. The boosters in blue hats who made the trip south cheered raucously, while the rooters in red sat stonefaced and silent, as the scoreboard screamed the harsh truth at them: 11-2. Mickey Cochrane had accomplished something quite remarkable: he had hit for the cycle. (Remarkable, yes, but hardly shocking. He would go onto to hit for the cycle in 1932 and 1933, and is thus one of very few MLB players with multi-cycle games.)

Things would turn ugly moments later, as Durbin cracked Simmons in the head with a pitch. Both benches cleared, and Connie Mack stared coolly at Durbin while walking out to check on Simmons, but sanity prevailed, and Durbin was immediately yanked for JA Happ. (Simmons, as hard boiled as they come, stayed in the game.)

Pat the Bat added a couple of late inning RBIs, but by then fans of both teams were already deep in discussion about whether or not the A’s were gong to hit Blanton as hard as they hit Moyer. And after his epic performance in a must win game, an old debate, heard often in Philadelphia when our grandfathers and great-grandfathers walked the city streets, was dusted off and presented anew: Is Mickey Cochrane the greatest catcher of all time?

GAME NOTES: You can check out the box score and play by play here…The A’s had 7 hits in the first 19 innings of this Series. They had 11 hits in the first 4 innings of tonight’s game…After Moyer and Durbin imploded, the rest of the Phillies bullpen pitched quite well, giving up 4 hits and no runs in 4.1 innings of work…While Al Simmons (3-5, 2 RBI) and Mickey Cochrane (4-6, 5 RBI) broke out of their slumps in a big way, Jimmie Foxx continues to struggle, going 0-4. He’s now 1-12 in the Series…1929 World Series hero Howard Ehmke pitched adequately, but Mack obviously had plans to make this game a “Pitch by committee” affair, as 5 different A’s took the field and Ehmke only went 3 innings…Jimmy Rollins is having an excellent Series so far, going 5-12 with 4 runs scored and 3 stolen bases.



  1. Ken Bland

    October 28, 2013 at 5:26 pm

    Madson pitched 2 innings both of the last 2 games. Not overkill with a day off, but maybe that catches up if the series goes deep.

    I want my money back if Double X doesn’t get it going by series end. 0-4 in a Moyer start doesn’t jive with reality. If Mr. Mack had unloaded him to the Red Sox in front of the modern day fan base, the A’s would have been Kansas City bound a LOT sooner. Mr. Mack’s fun to reminisce about, but he’d get crushed by Philly fans if he ran his operation like that before generations later fans. Which, conversely, might mean Rube wouldn’t be so hated back in the day.

  2. Johnny Goodtimes

    October 28, 2013 at 5:41 pm

    An interesting point, Ken, but the problem with Mack was that he also owned a large percentage of the team, and when the Great Depression came along, he was really in deep trouble. Fans stopped coming to the games, and he had no way to pay his stars. He also thought he could do what he did in 1915…sell off the stars, have a few down years, then rebuild with young players and a few wily old vets. Sadly, he tricked himself into thinking that because he had done that once he could do it again.

    Yeah, putting Madsen in for two innings in an 8 run game is just the kind of thing Charlie would do every now and again to really drive the fan base crazy. Let’s see if it burns them down the road.

    • Ken Bland

      October 28, 2013 at 7:26 pm

      The rumor is that every person in this world has a twin. Mr. Mack, say hey to Charles O. Finley. Although I suppose Finley ran his business a little more by choice than Mr. Mack’s necessity. Even ownership can make a club fun to follow. At least the A’s rekindled their early 20th century success, even if what we’re following in this series died emphatically a couple years post ’29.

  3. Matt E.

    October 29, 2013 at 5:23 pm

    Love the Dream Series! The only complaint I have is that the A’s seem to be seriously handicapped by the simulation for never having seen a slider, to the point that the team seems incapable of generating any offense (at least until Game 3). I hope the simulation is at least allowing them to adjust to it. Otherwise this Dream Series – and probably other sequels like it – won’t be very interesting.

    Speaking of sequels, are there any plans for more? Like 1980 Phils vs. 1930 A’s? Or 1915 Phils vs. 1914 A’s?

    • schmenkman

      October 29, 2013 at 7:13 pm

      I wouldn’t have thought that the simulation included that level of detail, to the point of specifying the types of pitches thrown and how well batters handled them, but I could be wrong.

      The way these simulations typically work (although this one could be different) is that it’s based on each player’s stats for the season, and how those stats might vary in the course of a game given the laws of probability.

    • Johnny Goodtimes

      October 29, 2013 at 7:22 pm

      Hey Matt, thanks so much! Yeah, the slider thing is really just part of our narrative of the series, not something that is used by the sim. It operates strictly off of stats, like schmenkman said. And as we saw in Game 3, the A’s still have plenty of pop in those bats.

  4. Ken Bland

    October 30, 2013 at 4:49 pm

    When Cochrane was the gold standard…

    A July 22, 1967, article in The Sporting News recapped some pretty heady praise McCarver inspired in his rookie season. Wally Schang, known both for his days as a catcher with Connie Mack’s Philadelphia Athletics and for the first three Yankees pennant-winning teams, said, “The kid reminds me of Mickey Cochrane. I don’t know if McCarver will hit with Cochrane, but he’s got Mickey’s same aggressiveness and speed. And as a kid, McCarver’s a pretty good hitter right now.”


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2016
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top