Hello and Welcome to the Philly Dream Series – Phillies Nation

Hello and Welcome to the Philly Dream Series

Philly Dream Series - Philadelphia Phillies vs Philadelphia Athletics

I don’t need to tell you that it wasn’t so long ago that October was the best month of the year in Philadelphia. For 5 straight seasons, we still harbored dreams of a World Series title after the regular season wrapped up. And in 2008, many of us experienced our most joyous month of being a sports fan ever. But the last two seasons have been duds, and October has become a month to gripe about Ruben Amaro, Jr. instead of watch baseball. Ripping Ruben is fun and all, but it’s nowhere near as exciting as rooting for the Phils on cool Autumn nights.

And so, in a small way, we want to try to bring a little bit of that feeling back. Oh sure, we won’t end up dancing down Broad Street and kissing total strangers when it’s all over, but we can try to relive the excitement of a team so many of us fell in love with, a team with a 45-year old pitcher, a shortstop with swagger, a goofy Hawaiian, and a rightfielder whose beard had a twitter account.

And at the same time, we want to introduce many younger fans to the greatest baseball team Philadelphia has ever produced, the 1929-1931 Philadelphia A’s. This was a team that took on Ruth, Gehrig and Lazzeri in their primes and CRUSHED THEM. In 1929, they won the pennant over Ruth and friends by 18 games. In 1930, they finished 16 games ahead of the Yanks, and in 1931, it was 13.5. Those great Yankees teams that sportswriters always gush about as the Greatest Team of All Time? For three years, they needed a good pair of binoculars to see the A’s in the standings.

It wasn’t a fluke. Four of those A’s winded up in the Hall of Fame, as did their legendary manager, Connie Mack. But because the team moved to Kansas City in the 1955, and then to Oakland in the 1960, those great ballplayers who meant so much to our grandparents and great-grandparents get lost to history (In fact, an excellent Sports Illustrated article about them is titled, “The Team That Time Forgot“.) We at Phillies Nation thought that, because Philly has such great baseball fans, that maybe a few of them would want to learn a little bit more about undoubtedly the greatest team in Philly baseball history, and one of the greatest teams in all of baseball history.

We want to have some fun with this project, and not just recite a bunch of old stats from the 1920s. So we decided to create a Philly Dream Series, between our beloved 2008 Philadelphia Phillies and the great 1929 Philadelphia Athletics. (Yeah, we realize that the 2008 team isn’t the best Phillies team ever, but the two best Phils teams, the 1977 team and the 2011 team, didn’t end up with the hardware.)

We’re going to be running the games through whatifsports.com, a really cool website that allows you to match up any two teams throughout time and then run simulated games with those teams. We’ll then be doing pre and post-game analysis on the games with some help from Penn professor Bruce Kuklick, who wrote the amazing book To Every Thing a Season, an absolute must read for any Philly sports fan. The book is about the history of Shibe Park. We also talk with Bryan Soderholm-Difatte, an historian on the Philadelphia A’s who recently presented his work at the annual SABR convention in Philly. Plus we’ll be meeting a fan of those ’29 A’s who lived on Lehigh Street, behind the right field wall of Shibe Park, whose parents sold tickets to their rooftop stands. We’ll even hear a few words from Brad Lidge about how he would pitch to sluggers on the ’29 A’s!

So for the next few weeks, instead of spending all of our time mumbling about Ruben and bemoaning our grim future, we’re going to take a fun trip to the past. We hope you’ll join us with the Philly Dream Series!



  1. Ken Bland

    October 17, 2013 at 4:16 pm

    How can you do a ’29 A’s pre game show with no mention of Howard Ehmke, who I have no doubt will throw this series on it’s ear.

    Couple years ago, I read a feature on a 1986 Mets-2008 Phils matchup, and the Phils won. That shocked me. So maybe this 29 A’s squad’s in trouble.

  2. Johnny Goodtimes

    October 17, 2013 at 5:54 pm

    Hey Ken, rumor has it that Ehmke will be starting Game 3. Though with Mack you never know.

    • Ken Bland

      October 17, 2013 at 8:30 pm

      I’d venture to guess that the way you rattle these stories off that anything I’d mention is stuff you’ve researched long ago, and know like the back of your hand.


      That Ehmke start, which, if your baseball education is through history, is a cornerstone to being educated was front row center news again when Konstanty started Game 1 of the 1950 Series against the Yanks. Eddie Sawyer references Mr. Mack’s Ehmke move in his almost forced move to Konstanty. For me, it draws a connection to Bob Walk in 1980, and a minimally related connection to the possibility of Shelby Miller were to emerging out of forgotten land if Cardinal pithcing gets so used in their potential final 2 V LA, and survive.

      The Konstanty/Ehmke parallel Sawyer drew in 1950 was Mr. Mack’s final year as manager at 88. And Charle tried to sound impressive about managing at 85. Not that Mr. Mack was necessarily coherent that year, but he managed. Hell, Gene Mauch was 38 when many of us attacked him for senility. God bless Gene for being a great baseball and family man, but he left himself so open to so much memory.

      But Mr. Mack’s last year included an exhibition game that found Vin Scully in the broadcast booth. Vin was 22, calling the decisions of Mr. Mack, who had started his MLB career in 1896. I don’t know if Vin’ll be there tomorrow night, but he was typical Vinnie as recently as yesterday. Vinnie would have been one year old when Ehmke made his legendary start for the A’s. It’s more likely that Vinnie said, “Pull up a chair, pop, and let’s listen to Ehmke pitch” than it is that he had red hair. Maybe not. The world had more red heads running around back then.

      Game 3’s a pretty pivotal game to use Ehmke. Maybe you boys are trying to emphasize the Mr. Mack by his own book side of him. I guess that’s easily enough achieved.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2016
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top