Gonzalez, Buchanan in Unlucky Spots Going Forward – Phillies Nation
2016 Spring Training

Gonzalez, Buchanan in Unlucky Spots Going Forward


Severino Gonzalez, image- Jay Floyd

The Phillies made some moves over the last year that beefed up their pitching staff and added prospects to other positions as well.  In doing so, they got rid of Cole HamelsJake Diekman, and Kenny Giles, in an effort to add plenty of young talent. The promising group that they’ve acquired have put a couple of Phillies pitchers in tough spots going forward.

Last year, Severino Gonzalez had an utterly forgettable season. In his seven starts at the big league level, he gave up 27 earned runs for an ERA of 7.92. In his Major League debut, he gave up seven runs to the Cardinals in less than three innings. It was one of the worst MLB debuts in history for a starting pitcher, as his game score of just 8 is tied for the 12th worst debut of all time. Oof.

There were questions then about his readiness for the big leagues–after all he was a rather young 22, and hadn’t had a ton of experience prior to being called up. And now there are some questions about when he will be ready to face MLB batters again, as he’s not exactly having a good time in Spring Training this year. In six innings pitched Gonzalez has given up five earned runs. And he was just optioned to Triple-A Lehigh Valley on March 22.

David Buchanan is somewhat in the same boat. He’s not as young as Gonzalez, and he had a pretty good 2014 season with the Phils. However, he had a 6.99 ERA last year in 15 games in 2015. He was put in a lot of bad spots, as I think he pitched a bit better than his numbers indicated. Still, he will not be a part of the Phillies rotation to start the 2016 season. He was optioned to AAA on March 15. Neither of them were on the 7-man deep depth chart on the Phillies website.

Both of these guys are being pushed out in favor of some other young arms like Jerad Eickhoff and Vincent Velasquez. There’s simply no room for them. Velasquez, who came over in the Giles trade, looks poised to blow MLB hitters away with his fastball at Citizens Bank Park. He’s got a good chance to be the #5 starter. Eickhoff, who was part of the Hamels deal, is pushing to be the #4 starter. He’s easing his way back after an injury, but he should be good to go by the time the season starts.

This is unfortunate news for the likes of Buchanan and Gonzalez, who could’ve been in contention for #4 and #5 in the starting rotation for 2016– if you asked me– last March. Right now, I just don’t see how they fit into the Phillies 25-man (and soon the 40-man) roster at all. The good news is that Eickhoff and Valesquez aren’t slouches by any stretch. They can become household names throughout the entire Philadelphia region if they both reach their ceiling.



  1. Philzrule

    March 23, 2016 at 7:18 am

    I’m sorry, is this actually a post defending the possibility of David Buchanan ever wearing a Phillies uniform again? I think he is the poster child for why Klentak went out and made the possible rotation more deep. Because when you’re relying on the barely 4A David Buchanans of the world to pitch valuable innings for your team, you’re kinda screwed. Great organizational guy, seems like he’s worked his butt off to get to where he is and has had some fun moments as a Phil, but c’mon. You don’t win with David Buchanan. We’ve seen his ceiling and his floor and neither one is appealing.

  2. George

    March 23, 2016 at 7:54 am

    These two guys are responsible for the positions they are in, not the fact that the team added some actual talent. Their performances are precisely why the GM’s (Amaro, and later, Klentak, made moves for more and probably better arms.

  3. Jay Floyd

    March 23, 2016 at 12:19 pm

    I don’t think it’s defense. Seems more like, “these poor guys didn’t cut it and their days are done” to me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2016
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top