Naming Jeanmar Gomez as closer makes no sense right now

As if the hints weren’t strong enough, Phillies manager Pete Mackanin has gone and done it. He’s named Jeanmar Gomez the team’s closer to start 2017.

But why?

Why the need to name a closer so early in the whole marathon? What, do the Phils have a 5-4 lead right now?

Gomez is a decent pitcher, maybe a seventh-inning type guy, at best. But he was the benefactor of an early season meltdown by closer David Hernandez (see what happens when you name closers early in the process?), and pitched well enough to keep the ninth-inning job throughout 2016. Even though we saw through the good numbers (a 2.59 ERA in the first half … despite just 26 strikeouts in 41.2 innings).

Of course, Gomez pitched worse in the second half. There was an 8.33 ERA. There were 21 strikeouts in 27 innings (actually better than the first half, but still …). Anyway, more of those ground balls got through for hits. More of those fly balls were hit into places without fielders.

You know, he regressed.

Gomez is close to the guy he was by the end of the season (4.85 ERA, 47 K in 68.2 IP). That’s not a “closer.” But Mackanin thinks differently.

“Premier [guys] have those kind of numbers,” he said to the media Tuesday.

In 2017, premier guys have an ERA closer to 1.00 than 5.00.

Which is why general manager Matt Klentak picked up Joaquin Benoit and Pat Neshek. Because they’re closer to “premier guys.”

So what now? Gomez gets to pitch the ninth inning in April? How many blown saves will remove him? Three? Four? Then what? Benoit steps in? Hector Neris? Does it matter?

For the 2017 Phillies, apparently closer matters. It matters so much that it was addressed on Feb. 14.

Maybe the Phillies should ensure their starters are healthy, that their relievers are decent enough to have jobs in the bullpen, and that – heck – it’s possible there are seven relievers *better* than Jeanmar Gomez. (It’s seriously possible.)

This is weird. It makes no sense. But the idea of a closer doesn’t make much sense anyway.

1 Comment

1 Comment

  1. bruce

    February 15, 2017 at 12:44 am

    As one would say, it’s his job (closer) to lose. I forget how many “saves” he had for the team last year but it was a lot (30 plus?). The manager obviously want to show respect and appreciation to Gomez for closing many of the games with saves last year. Gomez came to the rescue last season when the team were desperately looking for a closer. For those reasons, Manager Pete Mackanin rewarded Gomez in designating him as ‘closer” to begin this season. Even though Gomez does not have a overpowering fastball that the young fans associate with a closer, he nevertheless use his shrewdness and experience in pitching to contact to get his outs. So I would agree with the manager to give Gomez every opportunity to justify his continuing role as closer.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2017
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top