Raising Questions

Has Knapp earned a spot on the 2018 roster?

Quietly, Andrew Knapp has been a nice revelation for the Phillies, putting up respectable numbers for a rookie catcher. Hitting .261/.369/.381, his 0.7 WAR is good for 27th among catchers with at least 100 plate appearances. By comparison, catching mate Cameron Rupp (with 35 more plate appearances) is 38th in baseball with 0.2 WAR.

Knapp has, for the most part, been seeing more time behind the dish lately, as the Phils have recognized he’s been an offensive upgrade at the position.

One would assume that primary catching duties for 2018 would go to Jorge Alfaro, who has no option years left after this season and is such a highly touted prospect that – unless a trade occurs – there’s no way the Phils wouldn’t hand him a real opportunity to catch full-time. So, considering Knapp’s at least average offensive play, is he worth keeping as the second catcher next season?

It may be obvious to say “yes,” considering Knapp resembles a decent offensive player who’s still developing as a 25-year-old. But there are things to consider: Would the Phils want a veteran to teach Alfaro? Would the Phils want a more defensive-minded backstop to put the pressure off the defense a little? Would the Phils want someone who can frame some pitches?

The last thing has been a bugaboo for years. StatCorner does an excellent job tracking which catchers are best and worst at getting strike calls, and consistently, Rupp is below average. This year he’s third-worst in baseball behind Jonathan Lucroy and Salvador Perez. While Lucroy is having a down year at the plate, those two are typically guys you have because of their offense. Rupp’s offense is not strong enough to offset his defensive flaws.

As for Knapp, he’s also well below average in framing, according to StatCorner. So, again, is it wise for the Phils to pair Alfaro with another young backstop who’s not experienced and still learning the major league level?

Funny enough, the league’s best current framer, Atlanta’s Tyler Flowers, may be a free agent after this year. And while pitch framing shouldn’t be the only reason to make any decisions, Flowers is consistently very good at it and known league-wide as a good defensive catcher. It’s possible Flowers (who has morphed into a disciplined hitter and having his best offensive season yet) stays with Atlanta since the team holds an option on him, but keep an eye out.

Flowers has helped Atlanta turn into a moderate surprise this season. Having a solid defensive catcher has definitely helped their pitching and positioning. One wonders if the Phils could’ve benefited from a more stout defensive backstop, too.

But here we are. Knapp has been fine but below average defensively. Rupp has been slightly worse in both places. If Alfaro is the guy next year (that’s not in stone, but again, we’d have to assume), the Phils may be better served pairing him with an established defensive-first backstop.



  1. Mike Fassano

    July 20, 2017 at 12:13 pm

    I would include Alfaro in a trade for a young pitcher as good or better than Nola. Invite a couple of veteran catchers to Spring training, as well as Logan Moore, and see what develops. I’ve long been in favor of expanding the Major League roster to 27 players (a 3rd catcher & an extra arm in the pen). The cost to the team would be cheap

  2. Doug Dabenport

    July 20, 2017 at 12:19 pm

    I think game-calling ability and defensive prowess are the most important qualities in a catcher. I don’t think we really have anyine in the 40-man roster who is the answer at catcher. Look at the struggles the pitchers have gone through; Chooch didn’t let them have multiple bad outings, he worked with them to fix it. While much of that belongs on the pitching coach and bullpen coach, a quality defensive catcher is the biggest hole on the roster to me. I don’t care if Rupp, Knapp, or Alfaro could hit .350 with 40 home runs. If they c any call a game then they aren’t doing their jobs.

  3. denzen

    July 20, 2017 at 4:51 pm

    I think Knapp has shown growth behind the plate, with his all around game, in the time he has been up. I know it was a 10-3 game in the 9th, but I like how he took charge when Benoit threw 6 straight balls in yesterdays game. He went out to the mound, talked to 40 yr. old, and settled him down. I think Rupp’s best asset would be if he was behind the plate and a batter charged the mound.

  4. Walt

    July 21, 2017 at 6:34 am

    Great Defense up the middle is very important. Knapp has been out of position twice when taking throws from the outfield that cost us runs. You cannot say that about Rupp if you look back to his first season. This year Rupp’s BA is down which is characteristic of the sophomore season for most. You can be the best game caller in the business and if the pitcher cannot locate, if his pitches have no action it isn’t the catchers fault.

    The reality of this is Hoskins threatens two major league players jobs. Joseph has shown he has the ability and the smarts to stay on this team Hoskins hasn’t. At this point he is the pig in the poke. Bring Hoskins up september 1st and at least see what he does with the opportunity.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2017
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top