Offseason Overview: What do the 2018 Phillies look like?

The offseason has arrived.

As we count down the days until opening day (about 145), we’ll start to see movement in the form of free-agent signings, contract extensions, arbitration-year agreements and trade acquisitions. As Andy Williams once put it, it’s the most wonderful time of the year.

The rumors and prognostications are already flying, so we’re throwing our hat into the ring. This is our annual Offseason Overview, a series of pieces detailing what the Phillies have to do to accomplish their goals this winter. We’ll start here with a depth chart rundown, then we’ll go into individual issues later next week.

So, who is on Gabe Kapler’s roster next year?

At this point these choices feel like greater-than-85-percent certainties:

C – Jorge Alfaro
IF – Rhys Hoskins / Cesar Hernandez / Maikel Franco / J.P. Crawford / Freddy Galvis
OF – Nick Williams / Odubel Herrera / Aaron Altherr
SP – Aaron Nola / Vince Velasquez
RP – Hector Neris / Luis Garcia / Edubray Ramos / Adam Morgan

And there are internal options for spots:

C – Andrew Knapp / Cameron Rupp
IF – Brock Stassi / Jesmuel Valentin / Scott Kingery
OF – Dylan Cozens / Roman Quinn / Carlos Tocci / Cameron Perkins / Andrew Pullin
SP – Jerad Eickhoff / Jake Thompson / Ben Lively / Zach Eflin / Mark Leiter Jr. / Tom Eshelman / Drew Anderson
RP – Hoby Milner / Victor Arano / Ricardo Pinto / Yacksel Rios / Jesen Therrien

Things can change. Primarily someone can be traded; the most likely trade candidates include Hernandez and Rupp. You’ll notice Tommy Joseph isn’t listed above – it’s hard to imagine Joseph returning to the team in 2018. He’s also a major trade candidate. And it’s possible the Phillies decide underperformers like Franco and Velasquez aren’t worth roster spots, though it’s more likely the team wants to give these low-value players another chance to prove themselves worthy of spots.

If we take the above roster as gospel, then the Phillies have only 15 spots filled for next year, and as few as 12. One would imagine several of the internal candidates are given opportunities, but there’s still plenty of room for external additions.

Here are the most obvious places where the Phils can add externally:

  • Backup catcher – notably, a veteran presence to play behind Alfaro and/or Knapp or Rupp.
  • Sixth infielder – notably, a power-leaning hitter with third base ability.
  • Fourth outfielder – notably, a multi-position, low-grade, multi-tool player.
  • Top-line starting pitcher – notably, a league-top-40 pitcher around Nola’s ability.
  • Mid-line starting pitcher – notably, a durable, league top-75 pitcher capable of 50 percent quality starts.
  • Fifth reliever – notably, a veteran capable of filling in late-and-close situations early in 2018.

This offseason should be devoted to ensuring a pitching core for the future, as internal options haven’t yet proven worthy. The good thing is a pitching core can be as small as two starters, so the move is to find an arm close to that of Nola. Getting a mid-line starter – something better than Clay Buchholz in 2017 or even Charlie Morton in 2016 – is also relatively essential.

Filling in the offense is not so crucial, though Matt Klentak and Co. should creatively throw resources at veterans and low-risk fliers. This is the time you can find your Shane Victorino or Jayson Werth, the role player that blossoms into a true star for your contending club. Fourth outfielder is one such place where a surprise can yield fruit.

Starting Monday we’ll tell you what we’re thinking the Phils should do for the most necessary spots: fourth outfielder, starting pitcher one and two, and fifth reliever. Sunday we’ll look deep at the pitching market.

Welcome to the offseason. Should be a fun one.



  1. donald schell

    November 4, 2017 at 9:18 am

    Kingery will be the most valuable piece for 2018. Forget Hernandez-Galvis-Rupp-Joseph- Think Alfaro-Hoskins-Kingery-Crawford-Franco-Cozens-Herrera-Williams

    • sportsdoctor

      November 4, 2017 at 10:52 am

      Cozens does not see the majors until mid summer, maybe. Remember, his numbers at AAA were not great. Too many K’s, not enough contact. Plenty of power, but his season in AAA is his chance to make necessary adjustments. Altherr is a big piece in this line up. 20+ HR potential, good oontact, and one of the better defensive OF’s the team has (defense will be a priority moving onward).

  2. Steve (Tampa)

    November 5, 2017 at 6:40 am

    Cozens needs to start making significantly more contact at AAA before he becomes an option for the big club. Altherr is one of your primary three right now, and I suspect a healthy Quinn, a big if itself, is given a long look in ST.

    I really think this winter is the time to really shop Cesar. His value his as high as it is going to be, and they should be able to acquire a SP in return.

    As for outside trade targets, I like Odorizzi and DSalazar with Chatwood and a reunion with HKendrick my FA targets. An impactful BP arm also o the wish list

  3. Richard Mooney

    November 5, 2017 at 4:27 pm

    I don’t understand why every time I read one of these pieces, the writers are so quick to pencil in Velasquez a starter. His M/O has consistently been, effective for 3 or 4 innings, and then loses it. He seems to me a more efficient option as a long reliever, rather than as a starter.

  4. Craig Glessner

    November 6, 2017 at 1:58 pm

    I completely agree with Velasquez as a relief pitcher, I think Eflin and Leiter may be better there as well. I couldn’t help but notice that Nick Pivetta was not mentioned as a pitcher. Cozens and Quinn need to earn their way onto the roster, we should look at them in the spring but we can platoon Hoskins in left field every now and then and put Franco or Alfaro at first for that day.

  5. betasigmadeltahag

    November 7, 2017 at 10:27 am

    I also think Hernandez is the key trade to be made this off season. I also think Rupp could be a decent back up unless you can get a really good defensive veteran catcher that can help Alfaro calling games. My big thing is not to wait on Kingerly, he should be starting 2nd basemen in April. Crawford as your utility player. I really think with the right hitting coach Franco can get closer to his potential, he showed up late in the season when he was being pushed a little and was losing playing time. I think he is still too young to give up on, especially where the PHillies are at right now. I think an infield of Hoskins, Kingerly, Galvis and Franco would be a defensive power house. And with Williams, Altherr and Herrera would be a good starting outfield.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2017
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top