Phillies Nation


Predicting the 25-man roster: Feb. 25 version

Pfc. Dalton Precht / Wikimedia

The spring training games have begun. And everyone’s doing a 25-man roster prediction. Here’s mine.

Cameron Rupp
Andrew Knapp

Matt Gelb thinks a third catcher may be installed to start the year, to ease the burden for Knapp and provide a bit of veteran stability. While not a bad idea, I think the Phils will want Knapp to earn his keep as a backstop just as much as at first base (or simply off the bench in pinch hitting situations). A veteran catcher would only be a cosmetic addition with only small clubhouse benefit. Also, Rupp basically is a veteran now.

Tommy Joseph
Cesar Hernandez
Maikel Franco
Freddy Galvis
Andres Blanco
Hector Gomez

Five of these six spots are already in place, but the sixth is the one I continue to debate. The Phillies could drop the sixth infielder and simply carry six outfielders, since Chris Coghlan can play nearly every defensive position. But I’m not sure Daniel Nava is a favorite over Gomez, who has sneaky power that came out last year in Korea (21 home runs). He also plays third base; both Blanco and Coghlan can handle the hot corner in a pinch, but I’d bet the Phils want a more stable backup option for the streaky Franco.

Howie Kendrick
Odubel Herrera
Michael Saunders
Aaron Altherr
Chris Coghlan

Coghlan should win the battle because of his position flexibility, but Nava is an option. Otherwise this group is set. There is a scenario where Roman Quinn wows everyone again this spring and makes the team, which means Kendrick becomes an OF/2B option, which means Coghlan is probably the fall guy. I kind of want that scenario (because I want Quinn starting 162 games in the outfield this year).

Jeremy Hellickson
Jerad Eickhoff
Aaron Nola
Vince Velasquez
Clay Buchholz

The easiest group to predict, though it’s possible Buchholz is a tire fire in spring training and the Phils aggressively go with Jake Thompson or Zach Eflin. It’s more likely someone gets hurt, leading to Thompson or Eflin to move into the rotation. Let’s not wish for that.

Jeanmar Gomez
Hector Neris
Joaquin Benoit
Pat Neshek
Edubray Ramos
Joely Rodriguez
Adam Morgan

Again, an easier group to predict. The real battle is that last spot, which Morgan gets because of his left-handedness and the likeliness the Phils need a guy to pitch three to four innings early in the season (love those early season blowouts and/or rain delays!). Everyone else is practically pitching to be an injury replacement. First guy in? Michael Mariot, who has the best stuff of the invitees. Watch for Pedro Beato and old friend Luis Garcia, about whom Pete Mackanin recently raved.


Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2021
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top