Too little, too late for Cesar Hernandez

It’s time for the Phillies to move on from Hernandez at second base after another empty season.

If you want to go ahead and say that this has been a roller coaster of a season for Phillies second baseman Cesar Hernandez then you would be on a really exaggerated summer coaster ride.

What this season has demonstrated as well as any in recent memory is exactly what I was saying about him before it even began – it’s time for him to go.

Hernandez has some of the most empty and inconsequential offensive statistics in the game, his defense is nothing special, and at age 29 next season he should not be considered a piece for a future contending Phillies ball club.

This season began with Hernandez hot. Over the Phillies first 43 games through May 19 he was slashing .282/.392/.448 with six homers, 15 RBI, 34 runs scored and nine stolen bases. That would represent the roller coaster upward climb.

Then on May 20, Hernandez wrapped up a road trip in Saint Louis by going 0-3. It was the start of that roller coaster drop-off. And unlike most roller coasters, this one would not be over quick, nor would it lead to a series of thrilling ups and downs.

From that May 20 game through nearly the entirety of summer, Hernandez’ performance would plummet through a prolonged, nauseating, lineup defeating drop.

Across 93 games through September 3, Hernandez hit just .237 with a .309 slugging percentage. Over more than twice the number of plate appearances as in his quick start he hit one fewer home run and stole one fewer base.

It’s not as if Hernandez has been playing outstanding defense. His 1,217.2 innings played is the third-most of anyone at second base in all of Major League Baseball this year. According to Fangraphs he ranks just 12th on their Advanced Defensive Index and 13th in Defensive WAR at the Keystone.

And still, manager Gabe Kapler kept writing his name into the starting lineup. Hernandez has started 138 of the Phillies 146 games through Friday night.

Hernandez made $5.1 million this season and will be arbitration-eligible this coming off-season. He will most certainly be looking for a raise, possibly to the $10+ million per year mark. He cannot become a free agent until after the 2020 season.

There will be a bevy of free agent second basemen or players who could be used at the position who will be hitting the market this winter. The list includes potentially enticing names like Brian Dozier, DJ LeMahieu, Jed Lowrie, Daniel Murphy, Ian Kinsler, and Asdrubal Cabrera. But each has already reached age 30, and all will be hoping for expensive contracts at multiple years of commitment.

With two years remaining until his own free agency, and with those years coming in his ages 29 and 30 seasons, it is entirely possible that Phillies GM Matt Klentak could convince some contending general manager to give up a young prospect with reasonable upside in a trade for Hernandez.

Corey Seidman for NBC Sports Philadelphia speculated earlier this month on a possible return for Hernandez:

“At this point, the Phillies won’t be able to find great value for Hernandez. But they should be able to land a reliever coming off a good year from a team in need of a second baseman.”

The Phillies have their future at the position already in-house. Scott Kingery won a minor league Gold Glove at second base just last year when he hit .304 with 26 homers, 29 doubles, 29 steals, and 103 runs scored with the Triple-A Lehigh Valley IronPigs.

It’s time for the Phillies to commit and turn second base over to Kingery. (Photo by: Lauren McLaughlin)

Yes, Kingery struggled during his rookie season this year in Major League Baseball. The 24-year-old has slashed just .227/.268/335 with seven homers, 33 RBI, 10 steals, and 51 runs scored over 448 plate appearances across 134 games.

However, this was Kingery’s first taste of big-league life, and it arguably came under extreme duress. After playing just two minor league games at shortstop, Kingery was asked to become the Phillies starter at that vital position for much of this season.

Kapler has started him 90 times at shortstop and played him in 106 total games there. Meanwhile, Kingery has seen action in just four games at his natural second base position, with only two starts. He hasn’t gotten a start there since April 16 and has not played the position at all in the last three months.

As I described in a piece earlier this month, Kingery has been mishandled this year by the Phillies. I believe grossly so. As I wrote in that piece: “Put him at second base, and he will thrive. His record tells the tale. The proof is in the pudding. Pac-12 Player of the Year. Paul Owens Award winner. Minor league All-Star and Gold Glove Award winner.

I also believe that with a full year of MLB experience under his belt, and with the increased comfort level that would come in returning to his natural position, that Kingery will begin to thrive offensively next season.

During spring training back in March the Phillies signed Kingery to a six-year contract. It gave him more guaranteed money than any drafted player who had never played in MLB in the game’s history. They were presumably showing some level of commitment to Kingery and a belief in his abilities.

In the last 10 days, Hernandez has again heated up somewhat. Over nine games during that time he has hit .343 with a .415 on-base percentage. But it is too little, too late to salvage his season, let alone his Phillies career.

The improved stretch might indicate to some that the Hernandez roller coaster has finally bottomed out and is rising again. But the fact is that his numbers remain empty. He has no home runs, one stolen base, and two runs scored in those games.

It is time for the team to fully commit. It is time to dump Hernandez and turn the page from another failed 2012-17 player. Hand the starting job at second base to Kingery for the 2019 season and beyond, taking another step towards a brighter Phillies future.






  1. Gerald Kulpa

    September 15, 2018 at 5:22 pm

    One GLARING error Made by Klentak was trading Freddy Galvis(the BEST defender in their infield /SS, who also could and DID play Centerfield) Hernandez is mediocre and capable of ONLY playing 2nd.Kingerys year was derailed by the Ill fated supersub experiment, put him at his natural position. He will thrive next season, same. Goes for Hoskins. I’m a Quinn fan as well his offense /defense will improve this club as long as he can stay healthy. Finally Do NOT give up on Alfarro, sign Ramos despite them Both being Right hand hitters for the best catching tandem in BB

  2. pamikeydc

    September 15, 2018 at 10:16 pm

    He can be a utility player next year if you want to start Kingery, no? And Kingery had those minor league numbers you mentioned above in AA AND AAA correct ?? They weren’t just in AAA?!

    • Matthew Veasey

      September 16, 2018 at 11:31 am

      That is correct, Kingery has pretty much hit everywhere he has been before this rookie MLB season: college, High-A, Double-A, Triple-A. And for me, no, Cesar cannot be a utility player. It’s time to wash the bad taste of 2012-17 out of Phillies fans mouths. One man’s opinion.

  3. Craig Glessner

    September 15, 2018 at 10:43 pm

    The real question is why isn’t Kingery starting now at 2nd instead of Hernandez, Kapler has made some terrible lineups this year. Hernandez couldn’t be a utility player because he can’t really play any other position he’s not even that good at 2nd I think it is time another team over values him and we move on with the infield of the future with Hoskins at first and Kingery at 2nd. The next move that has been obvious for so long is Velasquez going to the bullpen or a new area code. Take the rest of this season and use Williams, Odubel, and Quinn in the outfield every day to see how it looks Jose Bautista is OK but has no future here. Finish strong GO PHILLIES

  4. Tom G

    September 16, 2018 at 8:49 am

    Santana shoukd have been batting 1st all season…Kingery shoukd be getting back to his natural position. As there shoukd be our 4th outfielder. ODEBUL shoukd be traded with his favorable contract. QUINN should be our everyday CF…knowing his propensity for injury…Hernandez could be shopped but Utility could serve well…he had played some Center, so has the ability to last as super sub.

  5. Chuck

    September 16, 2018 at 9:21 am

    Except for Hoskins, Santana, and Hernandez, they are all utility players. This front office believes they are smarter than everyone else and does not allow talent to blossom or fail. The 39th man on the roster should not be a viable pinch hitting option for one of your starters no matter what the option.. Hernandez should have been dealt instead of Galvis. Galvis is a plus defender all over the field with baseball instincts. Hernandez is the second coming of Von Hayes. And is someone going to address the taking of third strikes next year? NO. Despite this game trending to five inning starters, this regime values pitches seen over contact.

    • Jeff Orbach

      September 23, 2018 at 12:10 am

      I would take Von Hayes over CEHE in a NY minute.

  6. Philip M. Keim

    September 19, 2018 at 12:20 pm

    The managing of the Phillies has been terrible. There is nothing close to a set line up with players, positions, or batting order. Every day is like “who’s on first.” Young players are being squandered by not getting consistent at bats in consistent positioning and batting order. One hopes that the damage to young players is reversible. There was no need to acquire Batista at all….stick with the players that got you there. Dylan Couzins should be playing now. He is a big power hitter who needs to get some MLB at bats. Williams is also a good player and Athere (sp) but have been in and out of the lineup all year. Plus, for some reason the manager has never liked Franco. If you want consistency, you need to be consistent. When Gabe says it takes him hours to make the line up, I cringe. What a bunch of over statistics inferring with the game. He breaks all the old rules of baseball and it’s not paying off, but damaging his players.

    • Matthew Veasey

      September 19, 2018 at 12:48 pm

      I agree with much of what you are saying. Management tried to supplement the young players with more proven vets, thinking that they could help push the club past its season-long deficiencies and prop up the 2018 playoff run. It hasn’t worked. As for the lineup experimentation, this is Kap’s first year as a big-league manager. Let’s see what happens in the future. The team is likely to improve by at least 14 or so games this year over 2017, so it’s certainly not a complete loss or waste.

  7. Jeff Orbach

    September 23, 2018 at 12:19 am

    I feel the Phillies have an over abundance of players who don’t have a fundamental knowledge of the game.

    The other day when Asdrubel Cabrera hit the blooper to left Cehe only made it to second, I don’t know why he couldn’t have wound up at 3rd. Odubel looks like he’s given up already. When you lead a team it can’t all be positive, you have to know who youve got to kick in the butt to make them perform, as well as who responds to positivity. Kapler will be on a short leash next year and might get fired before that if one or more of the free agents we want won’t play for a screwy manager.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2018
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top