Bryce Harper closer to a decision than Manny Machado?

Harper wearing his jersey at the 2018 MLB All-Star Game. Could his name be on the back of a Phillies jersey in 2019 and beyond? (Arturo Pardavila III/WikiCommons)

It has been roughly ten days since I last wrote anything regarding the Phillies pursuit of free agents Bryce Harper and Manny Machado. I said that I wasn’t going to write something every time some new rumor popped up, and I’m sticking to that here.

What has me back writing on the topic is not some new rumor that we’re hearing. Instead, it’s what we are not hearing that has me back on the topic.

Regarding the Harper situation, I am finding that the silence is deafening.

When is the last time that you heard or read any rumors regarding Harper from any legitimate, reliable source? It’s been awhile. The usual insiders and talking heads were reporting on claims of some unnamed “source” on a regular basis. Now, those reports appear to have dried up.

Contrast that with the Machado situation, where just this past week it became public knowledge that a new team, the San Diego Padres, had aggressively jumped into the hunt for the young superstar infielder.

It was Kevin Acee of the San Diego Union-Tribune who first broke the story on Friday that the Padres were the “mystery team” in on Machado, something that had been widely speculated for days prior:

“According to multiple sources aware of talks between the sides but not authorized to speak publicly, the Padres are pursuing the 26-year-old superstar with the intention of playing him at third base.”

A.J. Cassavell at MLB.com followed up on Saturday by logically presenting how the 26-year-old would slot into the San Diego present and future, stating “Machado’s fit with the Padres is probably better than it is almost anywhere else.

Dennis Lin at The Athletic tweeted on Saturday that the Padres were actively seeking a face-to-face meeting with Machado and his representatives.

What all of this continuing pursuit of Machado tells me is that he has not yet decided. Despite much speculation that his decision was likely down to the Phillies and Chicago White Sox, that appears now to be nothing more than just that – speculation.

If Machado were that close to a decision and in a serious final process, why suddenly open up what have been months-long visits, considerations, and negotiations?

You would think that he and his reps would thank the Padres for their interest, but let the team know that he has been involved with others for weeks, if not months, and was preparing to make that final decision.

To have the process remain open, or to be re-opened, and allow San Diego to become a serious suitor this late says to me that Machado is not as far along in his decision-making process as some sources might lead you to believe.

On the other hand, there is nothing coming out on Harper. The Yankees, Dodgers, and Cubs all appear to be out. The last rumors widely circulating had the process narrowed to the Phillies, White Sox, and his old team, the Washington Nationals.

However, the more you really examine the Nationals and White Sox situations closely, the more neither team appears to be a logical fit.

Washington has already spent a lot this off-season to bring in free agent pitchers Patrick Corbin, Anibal Sanchez, and Trevor Rosenthal. They have looming negotiations with third baseman Anthony Rendon, who can become a free agent next off-season. And the Nats can replace Harper internally with two of the top young outfield prospects in the game in 20-year-old Juan Soto and 21-year-old Victor Robles.

The White Sox signed Alonso, who is Machado’s brother-in-law, earlier this off-season. (BubbaFan/WikiCommons)

The White Sox want to make a splash this off-season, perhaps as much as the Phillies. To that end, they have bolstered their bullpen with the additions of closer Alex Colome and setup man Kelvin Herrera via free agency.

But a strong clue as to the South Sider’s true desires can be found in their free agent position player additions. Chicago has signed both Yonder Alonso and Jon Jay this off-season.

Alonso is Machado’s brother-in-law and Jay is his good friend. As players, both are marginal additions. But as moral support for Machado, friendly faces to make a new locker room more comfortable, they could be invaluable.

What all of this continuing activity and interest in Machado tells me is that no decision is coming soon. What the silence surrounding the Harper situation tells me is the exact opposite.

I believe that it is very possible that Harper has indeed made a final decision. In that case, the silence right now would be due to his agent, Scott Boras, and the signing team going through the “dotting the i’s and crossing the t’s” contract process.

With Harper, there are likely to be many details, including bonus incentives, “out” clauses, and both team and player options. And he would need to undergo a thorough physical exam as well.

Hey, I could be wrong. But to me, it smells like we may be near an end to the Harper situation. And to me, the Phillies remain the most likely team to be slotting the 26-year-old outfielder into the middle of their lineup this coming season. On Machado, well, no end appears to be in sight, and I wouldn’t lay money on the Phillies being involved at this point. We shall see.






  1. Dale

    January 27, 2019 at 4:42 pm

    Good article. Was thinking same thing. No news about mystery teams coming from Boras camp.
    Maybe something is close. Hope it’s the Phillies. Then sign Moustakas and trade Franco.
    Trout in 2020. Sign me up!

  2. Craig Glessner

    January 27, 2019 at 5:32 pm

    First why would you possibly want moustakus over Franco? Second does anyone else think something needs to change with the free agency signing period. What is a mystery team there are 30 teams it’s not like the Omaha Cornstalks are going to sign Harper. Here’s the thing teams make an offer players and agents decide what offer they like the best. That process should not last 3 months. I’m tired of hearing what these players and agents think they are worth and holding out because nobody is matching that. Look at Arrieta last year he found out what his real value was and quite honestly he was way overpaid for what his numbers were last year. Greed is killing this game if players like Harper and Machado think the game will stop if they don’t play for someone. Guess what someone else will take their spot ask the guy who took a day off and Gehrig took his position. Speed up free agency is all I’m saying remember without the fans and the owners there is no need for players if you don’t agree with that then answer me who pays the salaries for these players(the owners do and indirectly we the fans do when it costs over $100 to go to 1 damn game).

    • schmenkman

      January 27, 2019 at 8:16 pm

      Why should the process not last 3 months? It’s these players’ one shot at the big money, and I don’t begrudge them taking as long as it takes to get the best deal they can.

      Besides some ADHD fans, who cares how long it takes?

      • Keith

        January 28, 2019 at 12:15 am

        What a very in insightful reply. ADHD? Craig is 100% right here and you are ridiculous.

        • schmenkman

          January 28, 2019 at 5:26 am

          Now that’s insightful. I know that if I (or most people IMO) were in their shoes, i’d be doing the same thing.

  3. Bigdog

    January 27, 2019 at 7:55 pm

    Shame on mlb for this. Off season process must change unless mlb is ok with dropping in popularity. Very distasteful when the average fan observes agents, players, owners fighting over obscene amounts of money and trying to squeeze the highest dollar out of each other. It’s disgusting.

    • schmenkman

      January 27, 2019 at 8:19 pm

      Oh come on, this can’t be serious.

      Quite the opposite, it has kept baseball in the news throughout the off-season.

      The Phillies in particular have also made one of the major trades of the off-season, and spent the 4th most of any MLB team so far.

  4. Craig Glessner

    January 27, 2019 at 9:37 pm

    Well I know if I only signed for $250 million I may have to eat ramen noodles and drive a used Ford focus but if I hold out for $300 million I can live the life of an average person.

  5. MaineRob

    January 28, 2019 at 7:06 am

    Not only the long, snail’s pace slog, but there are tens of dozens free agents out there waiting for these two to sign. The Phils still have holes to fill and they can’t do it until MacHarper makes up its mind.

    Back in the day, the Winter Meetings meant something. Trades were made, free agents signed, and then the anticipation of pitchers-catchers reporting took on a special meaning as we envisioned a set lineup. Not nowadays, at least for me.

    A portion of my day is spent wondering whether this is THE decision day. Will MacHarper sign in the first week following the NFL division championship? No. Will it sign during SB week? My guess is no. How soon will it sign after the SB? Will the parade have to happen first? I know it shouldn’t preoccupy my mind, but it does, unfortuantely.

    I absolutely agree that something has to change. This ugly situation has to be resolved. Somehow, Joe Fan needs to be acknowledged in some manner.

  6. Jeff Orbach

    January 29, 2019 at 9:29 am

    This should not be preventing the Phils from acquiring a back up catcher as there are many free-agents still available. Unless they are waiting to make a trade and want to see if they have surplus infielders or outfielders to deal.

    • John h cyples

      February 1, 2019 at 9:48 am

      Curt flood ruined baseball. All by himself.

      • schmenkman

        February 1, 2019 at 10:56 am

        Mr. Middleton, is that you?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2019
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top