Phillies Nation

Phillies Nuggets with Tim Kelly

Re-signing J.T. Realmuto doesn’t make Sixto Sánchez trade a wash

Whatever you think of the tenures that Matt Klentak and Andy MacPhail had at the forefront of baseball operations for the Philadelphia Phillies, they did a good job of anticipating what the free-agent market for J.T. Realmuto would lead to.

J.T. Realmuto has signed a deal to return to Philadelphia. (Andy Lewis/Icon Sportswire)

Sure, a global pandemic probably affected Realmuto’s market. The Phillies may have also gotten lucky that teams like the New York Mets and Toronto Blue Jays elected to go in other directions with their money this winter, but that was part of the gamble that they made in letting Realmuto reach the free-agent market. While‘s Todd Zolecki reported that at one stage Realmuto was targeting more than $200 million, he didn’t get even get $150 million ultimately. Not even close, really. Five years and $115.5 million is a deal that comes with a record $23.1 million average annual value for a catcher, but it’s a far cry from what Realmuto and his agent, Jeff Berry, had hoped for at the beginning of the offseason.

However, while Klentak and MacPhail bet correctly on how Realmuto’s free-agent stint would play out, the jury is still out on how history will view the February of 2019 trade that allowed them to acquire the All-Star catcher. Re-signing Realmuto doesn’t mean that the Phillies won the trade, nor does it essentially mean things are a wash.

In his first two seasons with the Phillies, Realmuto graded out as the top catcher in the sport, making the National League All-Star team and winning a Gold Glove in 2019. And yet, despite elite production, the Phillies don’t have a playoff appearance to show in either of Realmuto’s first couple seasons in red pinstripes. They haven’t even posted a winning season with Realmuto.

That, of course, is not the fault of Realmuto. If he wasn’t on the Phillies in 2019, they probably would have been more like a 75-win team, as opposed to the one that went 81-81. Certainly, though, when the Phillies traded for Realmuto, they did so under the belief that they were ready to win right away. Why else would you trade for a catcher that’s in his late-20s? One popular theory has been that acquiring Realmuto helped seal the deal with Bryce Harper in free agency, but while he acknowledged that it probably didn’t hurt their chances, managing partner John Middleton told Phillies Nation last October that he didn’t believe that acquiring Realmuto was something that the team absolutely needed to do to get Harper to sign on the dotted line.

Realmuto is now signed through the 2025 season, but it stands to reason that as a catcher who will turn 30 in March, he’s probably at the back-half of his prime. So, if the Phillies aren’t able to compete in a meaningful way over the next two seasons, you’re left to wonder if the calculation that ended in trading away Sánchez was wise, even if Realmuto ends up being a Wall of Famer.

While he playing for the Double-A Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp in 2019, it was easy to overlook Sánchez, especially as Realmuto put up a monster season. In 2020, though, Sánchez looked dominant at times in his first major league action, posting a 3.46 ERA and 3.50 FIP in his first seven major league starts, including a seven-inning complete game over the Phillies in a crucial series in September. As the Phillies sat at home for a ninth consecutive October, Sánchez helped the Marlins to return to the postseason for the first time since 2003, even defeating the Chicago Cubs in the opening round of the National League playoffs.

Though he won’t be eligible for the National League Rookie of the Year Award in 2021, Sánchez is still technically a prospect. With that in mind, Baseball America was so impressed with his early returns at the major league level that they ranked him as the top overall pitching prospect in the sport earlier this month.

If Sánchez has a five-year stretch as one of the league’s elite arms, giving that up, especially for a franchise that doesn’t regularly churn out elite prospects, would be a tough pill to swallow. It would be that much more difficult if the Phillies don’t have significant team success while Realmuto is at the height of his powers. You’d be hard-pressed to find an executive in the sport that would take the top catcher in the sport over one of the 15 or 20 best starting pitchers.

So while it’s excellent news, at least in the short-term, that the Phillies re-signed Realmuto, don’t take a victory lap on the trade just yet.


  1. The Top 10 Phillies Home Runs Of The 2020 Season
  2. More Details On J.T. Realmuto’s New Contract
  3. Here’s What Didi Gregorius Is Reportedly Looking For In A New Deal
  4. Zero Players Elected To Baseball Hall Of Fame In 2021
  5. Sixto Sánchez Is Now The No. 1 Pitching Prospect In Baseball
  6. Phillies Sign Veteran Righty To Minor League Deal
  7. Former Phillies Pitcher Says He Didn’t Purposely Hit Scott Rolen
  8. Phillies Sign Highly-Touted Catching Prospect Among Numerous International Signings
  9. Phillies Should Avoid Banking On Spencer Howard As Key Starter In 2021
  10. The Top 10 Phillies Home Runs At Citizens Bank Park


  1. Brent

    January 27, 2021 at 5:39 pm

    Trades are not a zero-sum evaluation. The Phillies believed they were starting a contention window, and they made a win-now trade. The Marlins believed they needed a high-end pitching prospect to further along their rebuild, they got Sixto. A trade is allowed to work out for both sides given where they are in their competitive cycle. The trade was perfectly fine for the Phillies, and I will not entertain looking at trades in the form of who “won” or “lost” them.

  2. Jim McTear

    January 27, 2021 at 6:14 pm

    Why the negative spin, Tim Kelly? Had they not signed JT, you would have been all over the Phillies. Were you under pressure to get a story in?? Just another example of the media & you stirring the pot!

    • JB

      February 11, 2021 at 7:15 pm

      No negative spin. He’s right on—and it’s refreshing to hear someone in the media say it, instead of the lazy narrative that signing JT makes that trade all right. The fact of the matter is, yes, they needed to resign JT to lessen the sting of seeing Sixto succeed already. But, no, that still doesn’t make the trade a good one. And this is no 20/20 hindsight…I felt it was a bad trade when they did it. Because as Tim said, they’re aren’t many baseball people who would trade a true top of the line starter (even as a prospect) for an all-star catcher. After all, you can win the World Series without a stud catcher, but it would be impossible to even make the playoffs without good pitching. Thus, I believe history will judge this a bad trade in total. Ask yourself, would you trade Sixto for JT now? No way. And that’s how the trade will ultimately be graded unless the Phillies somehow win a World Series in the next five years.

  3. David Hunter Bishop

    January 28, 2021 at 7:55 am

    Extremely pleased to retain Realmuto, but still gaping holes up the middle at SS and CF, and a serious lack of left-handed pitching.

    • Philly For Life

      January 29, 2021 at 2:50 pm

      LHP Miller from Stanford is probably a year out..

Leave a Reply

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2021
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top