The awkward attempt Nick Castellanos gave on a sixth inning Jake Fraley double Wednesday night might have seemed like the byproduct of a few different factors working against the Phillies right fielder. All season – all six games, that is — Castellanos’ glove has not passed the eye test. Perhaps his defense, which took massive strides in 2023 after a dreadful 2022, is regressing to the mean. It’s possible he’s carrying the struggles of a .150/.292/.150 slash line with him to the outfield. Maybe Father Time is simply starting to catch up to the 32-year-old. More milk than wine, so to speak.
Apparently, according to manager Rob Thomson, the main culprit is something else entirely.
“Casty was telling me the other day that the new scoreboard is kinda — he’s gotta get used to it,” Thomson said.
“Because he feels like he’s right on top of the scoreboard, and he’s not. He’s got a lot more room. So might take a little time to figure that out.”
The Phillies did not change their outfield dimensions over the offseason. They massively overhauled the out-of-town scoreboard, reducing the “out-of-town” part and replacing it with advanced stats, advertisements and more room for video displays. But it’s still in the same place as it was last year and the year before, which saw Castellanos play a combined 163 games in Citizens Bank Park’s right field.
That doesn’t mean it doesn’t look entirely different. The scoreboard is much more in-your-face than the unassuming, retro look of the previous two decades. Chasing a ball headed for a part of the scoreboard right in between a giant photo of Zack Wheeler and the number of vertical inches on his last pitch, all strewn in between a visually cacophonous display of red, purple, and blue lighting, might affect a fielder’s ability to orient himself within the area he’s supposed to patrol. No doubt.
But there are certain things a manager of a 5-1 team can get away with revealing about a player OPSing .900 with passable defense, which don’t go over as well when the team is 2-4 and the player is doing neither of those things. Chalk the scoreboard explanation up as belonging to bucket No. 2.
It would certainly benefit the Phillies’ defense if Castellanos can get used to the scoreboard in short order. But his defense is secondary, especially as long as Johan Rojas is stationed to his right. Castellanos needs to hit. He’s struck out in 7 of 20 at bats this season, and his 41% chase rate — something the Phillies focused on reducing, for all of their regulars, all offseason — is in the second percentile in all of MLB. The size of the sample would be a lot more reassuring if it didn’t follow a .119/.140/.262 Spring Training, but alas.
Unless those numbers turn around soon, it’ll be hard to look at Castellanos’ stats — standard or advanced — displayed upon the new scoreboard plastering Citizens Bank Park’s right field wall. Come to think of it, though, the harder those numbers to look at, the easier it should be to track a fly ball.
Must-read Phillies content
- Here’s the recap of Wednesday’s game, which included the double in question, by Bailey Digh.
- Tim Kelly has the latest on Taijuan Walker and Orion Kerkering’s injury rehab.
- Ty Daubert wrote an excellent feature on Carlos De La Cruz, who’s looking to beat the odds with size and power “you dream about.”
- Destiny Lugardo wrote about Bryce Harper’s historic three-homer game and how he hopes it’s the start of a Phillies run.
MORE FROM PHILLIES NATION
- Phillies 2024 Walk-Up Songs
- Phillies Cream Alternate Jerseys Appear To Be Different Shade In 2024
- Phillies Nation’s Top 10 Players For 2024
- Brian Snitker Declines To Give Examples Of Poor Treatment His Family Received At Citizens Bank Park
- Phillies Unveil, Explain Reasoning For New Out-Of-Town Scoreboard
- Cast Off By Braves, Jordan Luplow Hoping To Make Impact For Phillies In 2024
- Scott Kingery, Again, Prepares For Potential Final Season In Phillies Organization
- Phillies Expected To Have Jersey Ad Patch Deal By All-Star Break
- Phillies Will Celebrate Citizens Bank Park’s 20th Anniversary Throughout The 2024 Season
- Phillies 2024 Giveaway Schedule
Jim Pennewill
April 4, 2024 at 11:49 am
Question that I need to clarify something. Has Rojas hit a ball that reached the outfield grass yet. I know he has 1 hit, infield single, has stuck out 4 times, so that leaves 10ab’s. I remember a pop out to 2nd at least 5 groundouts, I watch all the games but have missed ab’s was just wondering if you have stat for that.
Andrew
April 4, 2024 at 2:51 pm
Signing Castellanos was a mistake the ink dried. He will be moved either via trade or DFA this offseason.
Pete
April 7, 2024 at 6:38 pm
Hopefully soon
Bawb Eff
April 4, 2024 at 4:41 pm
Castellanos seems totally out of it in the field and at the plate. It almost looks like he just doesn’t give a rip. And yes, that ball that Fraley hit should have been caught. I guess $20,000,000 just doesn’t buy you motivation like it used to. If he doesn’t pop his head out it’s only going to get worse when the fans start booing him. This is year three now. He had his “get used to Philly” year two years ago so he should be comfortable now.
Phil Smith
April 4, 2024 at 7:28 pm
This should phrighten all Phillies fans, when Marsh is sitting out against lefties, the Phillies have the worst hitting outfield in baseball, not even close. They need to send Rojas down to learn how to hit and bench or trade Castellanos.
SCLawDawg
April 4, 2024 at 4:49 pm
Phillies should have went after Soto or Bellinger in the off season. Castellanos should be traded or released in July. Harper being selfish should have went back to right field and the Phillies should have resigned Hoskins. They should’ve kept Kingery over Sosa or Merrifield. Go get Trout!, another typical Phillies season coming.
James Fitzpatrick
April 4, 2024 at 5:28 pm
Now it’s the scoreboard’s fault? What a lame excuse. He’s got that Bobby Abreu fear of the wall.
Barbara Jean
April 4, 2024 at 6:38 pm
There was some talk about trading Castellanos. At this point he needs to be anywhere but Philadelphia. We need to turn this start of a season around.
berksbaseball
April 5, 2024 at 8:26 am
Does the Scoreboard make him swing at pitches a foot outside and in the dirt????
Jk
April 5, 2024 at 9:30 pm
I said after they lost last year the following moves i should be GM. Trade castellanos, move harper back to right. Sign hoskins. Trade rojas for a new scooter for the phanatic . Replace the mgr for forcing rojas and castellanos down our throats sign a outfielder who hits for average maybe try and trade for one it is still early Dombrowski MaKE IT HAPPEN!!!!!
MM
April 6, 2024 at 6:23 pm
Slumps are slumps…. Offense, defense…. Darn and the season ends tomorrow!!!!
Give him a break… Next week it’ll be Stott or Bryce or…..
MM
April 6, 2024 at 6:24 pm
Just warming up….
Charles Dissinger
April 8, 2024 at 4:27 pm
Nick has to go NOW!