Phillies Beat with Destiny Lugardo

How Adolis García’s production so far compares to last year’s right field mix

Comparing Adolis García’s early-season struggles with production from Max Kepler and Nick Castellanos in 2025. (First two photos from left: Logan Gehman/Phillies Nation; Photo to the right: Madeline Ressler/Phillies Nation)

PHILADELPHIA — In the ninth inning on Friday night, Guardians superstar José Ramírez lined a splitter from Jhoan Duran that was bound for the corner in right field. Adolis García, drifting to his left, quickly cut off the ball and fired a perfect throw to second base for a huge first out.

Citizens Bank Park was in awe. The game stopped for the minute as fans applauded García for the incredible play.

The Phillies haven’t had an outfielder with an arm as powerful as García’s in a long time. It doesn’t always lead to dramatic outfield assists because some runners hesitate to take an extra base on him. He also gets the kind of jumps that make extremely difficult catches look relatively easy, judging by his three five-star catches made this season already, per Statcast.

“He’s a force in right field, that’s for sure,” interim manager Don Mattingly said on Friday night.

The metrics and the eye test back up the idea that García is one of the best defensive outfielders in baseball. It’s a massive upgrade over Nick Castellanos and even Max Kepler, but he has so far been a downgrade at the plate.

García has only one hit in his last 11 games. Mattingly gave him a day to reset during the last road trip. One long slump led to another. He went 0-for-22 from May 9 to May 16, recorded a base hit in his last at-bat on the 16th and is now in an 0-for-13 dating back to the 17th. His season OPS has dropped from .702 at the end of play on May 9 all the way to .596. Add that all up and he’s stuck in a 1-for-35 slump.

“The last homestand, I felt, ‘Man, this cat is on the way,'” Mattingly said about García on Saturday. “He’s shooting some balls in the middle the field, his outs to center field were hard. His at-bats looked better, then we kind of got off track. … A couple of bad matchups and you start questioning what you’re doing or whatever. As much as anything, you feel like it’s still there. You see it, the physical side of it.”

There is still plenty of time for García to get hot and make up those numbers, but Castellanos’ and Kepler’s numbers never looked this bad this late into the season. The lowest Kepler’s OPS was after April was .645 on Aug. 4. Castellanos’ .694 OPS to end the season was actually the lowest it had been all year after March. Both Phillies outfielders last year did have at least one bad stretch that mirrors the one García is going through right now. Castellanos had one hit in 34 at-bats last August. Kepler went 3-for-38 in May.

But it’s fair to wonder if this is a bad stretch or something more substantial. García has struggled at the plate over his last two seasons after his career year in 2023. He batted .225 with a .278 on-base percentage from 2024 to 2025. He was non-tendered by the Rangers last offseason and the Phillies picked him up in hopes of being able to unlock something offensively.

The $10 million price tag was more of an indicator of just how difficult it is to find right-handed power.

“I don’t know if (his struggles) are carrying over or he’s feeling pressure,” Mattingly said. “Now all of a sudden, it’s a, ‘What happened to me?’ type thing. In my mind, it’s always if it’s there once, it’s not gone, right? It’s just a matter of finding it again or getting it to click.”

Castellanos and Kepler were both never options to return. The Phillies went through a messy breakup with one and the other is currently suspended for PEDs. But the Phillies were hopeful that whoever they brought on to replace them would be an upgrade offensively for a lineup that is in desperate need of more depth. That’s not the case so far.

If García’s struggles continue, the solutions are not as obvious as they were last year. Justin Crawford loomed as a potential replacement for Kepler for nearly the entire season up until September, when Crawford was ruled out for the year with a concussion. Crawford is now up with the big league club as the starting center fielder on most days. His play in center field has improved recently, but he’s been just fine at the plate with a .689 OPS.

Somehow, Castellanos survived the year on the roster despite all of the drama that was going on behind the scenes. The addition of Harrison Bader along with Kepler’s improvement and Brandon Marsh continuing his very strong season allowed the Phillies to essentially phase Castellanos out of the lineup by September.

There’s not necessarily anyone in Triple-A who could be a threat to García’s roster spot. One prospect could eventually cut into García’s playing time.

Gabriel Rincones Jr., who is currently on a rehab assignment with the Jersey Shore BlueClaws, should be back with the IronPigs’ next week, per Phillies Nation’s Ty Daubert. He missed all of spring training and has been on the minor league IL all year with knee issues. If he hits and stays healthy, right field could once again become a platoon with Rincones playing strictly against right-handed starters and García starting against lefties and entering games once the opposing team brings in a left-hander to face Rincones.

Could that be a lever the Phillies pull before the trade deadline? It’s worth exploring everything they have before determining where to prioritize upgrades around the roster. It appears the Phillies will be shopping for a right-handed hitting outfielder for a third consecutive deadline, even if García does improve.

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2026
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top