Phillies Beat with Destiny Lugardo

Dave Dombrowski discusses Andrew Painter’s demotion, Phillies provide update on Adolis García

Andrew Painter was sent to Triple-A Lehigh Valley. (Brendan Baldwin/Phillies Nation)

PHILADELPHIA — The Phillies are pressing pause on Andrew Painter’s major league season.

The rookie right-hander was optioned to Triple-A Lehigh Valley following Wednesday’s start against the Miami Marlins. He allowed six earned runs in two innings. His season ERA is 7.06, the second-highest in the majors among pitchers that have thrown at least 65 innings.

It is not what the team nor player envisioned when he was brought up to the majors at the beginning of the year.

“We think the best thing for him is to kind of get a reset,” Dave Dombrowski told reporters on Thursday. Painter will throw side sessions over the next few days, then will make his first start of the year in Triple-A within the next seven to 10 days, Dombrowski estimated.

As for how the Phillies will fill his rotation spot at the major league level, they are not ready to announce anything yet. Right-handed pitcher Seth Johnson was recalled from Triple-A Lehigh Valley. The Phillies also selected the contract of right-handed pitcher Bryse Wilson, who is available for multiple innings out of the bullpen on Thursday behind starter Aaron Nola. Tanner Banks, who has been in the Phillies bullpen since the second half of 2024, was optioned to Triple-A.

Wilson could make the next start in the Painter spot, which comes up on Tuesday in Washington. They could do a bullpen game, though it wouldn’t be ideal.

“For me, it’s not the best scenario because you’re taxing your bullpen every five days, or you have a chance to without somebody that’s taking down four or five innings,” interim manager Don Mattingly said. “That puts you in a little bit of bind.”

There is a lot for him to work on. Painter’s fastball got crushed to the tune of a .404 batting average against. His calling card pre-Tommy John surgery was his fastball. He has thrown it only 33% of the time. He needs to get command of it back. It also has to look less enticing to the hitters.

Improving his delivery will be the main focus.

“Most of it is delivery-oriented, it’s what it comes down to because when he’s done some things with his delivery, which is going more directly to the plate rather than spinning off, he’s had more life,” Dombrowski said. “And you see it at times. He threw some pitches yesterday that were outstanding, but not on a consistent basis. So the feel is that when he does that, when he gives that effort going forward, his ball’s got more movement, he’s got more command of his pitches and his split looks better at that time, too. That’ll be the goal.”

The move down to Triple-A gives Painter and the Phillies more time to focus on these changes. It will be easier without the pressure that comes with getting results at the major league level for a team with championship aspirations.

“I think it was the best thing for him,” Mattingly said. “At this point, it’s hard to keep working and keep trying to get better and perform at the big league level. And he’s not the first guy this has happened to. It happens to 90% of the guys that are coming and going back. Very few guys just come and stick and then never see the minor leagues again.”

The Phillies are still hopeful that this is all a blimp in the radar and that Painter could be the star pitcher he was projected to be when he was lighting the minor leagues on fire in 2022.

“I think he’s going to be a very good pitcher,” Dombrowski said. “Again, it’s difficult. He’s coming off a situation where he had Tommy John surgery, so last year he was coming back from that. Sometimes, it takes a while to come back and be quite as effective. I mean, his stuff, his fastball is upper 90s, he’s got three good breaking balls, he’s got a split. He’ll command his pitches better when he gets his delivery refined. So we think he’s going to be a very good big leaguer.”

Adolis García officially out for the remainder of the season

The Phillies announced on Thursday that outfielder Adolis García will undergo surgery to repair his torn right latissimus dorsi on Wednesday, June 24. The recovery is six to eighth months, meaning he is officially done for the season.

In the meantime, Gabriel Rincones Jr. will take down at-bats in right field against right-handed starting pitchers. Against lefties, the outfield arrangement is Edmundo Sosa in left field, new trade acquisition Derek Hill in center field and Brandon Marsh in right. They are essentially platooning in two outfield spots, something they did at the end of last year with Marsh and Otto Kemp in left and Max Kepler and Nick Castellanos in right.

In the absence of another acquisition in the outfield, Rincones will get an extended opportunity in the coming weeks.

“We’ll see. He made a nice flash with the home run,” Dombrowski said. “But he’s gonna get every opportunity to contribute. I mean, that’s where you kind of have to see where he is too before you start making some decisions and where else you’re going with other needs that you have.”

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2026
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top