
Former third overall pick Alec Bohm is a free agent after seven seasons with the Phillies.
Bohm, who debuted in 2020, has had quite a career with the Phillies. He finished third in National League Rookie of the Year voting in 2020, was sent down the following year and established himself as a lineup regular after surviving a three-error game in April 2022.
Bohm got off to a terrible start, but finished the year as one of the few reliable bats in the lineup. From Opening Day to May 4, Bohm had a .429 OPS. From May 5 through the end of the year, Bohm had a .771 OPS. For comparison, Bryson Stott had a .774 OPS in that same time frame.
Did Bohm ever meet the high expectations set for him when he was drafted? No, but he was a mostly solid player throughout his tenure.
Should the Phillies bring him back for another year?
Here’s part three of Phillies Nation’s Stay or Go series. Vote in our poll below the article.
Past editions:
Destiny Lugardo — Site Director: Go
Bohm deserves all the credit in the world for proving people like me wrong and becoming the Phillies’ most consistent hitter over the last two months of the season. But I think it’s time for both sides to move. Bohm is adamant that his contact-first approach works best for him. I would be shocked if another organization got him to rethink his identity at the plate, but it’s not going to happen here.
Ty Daubert — Editorial Director: Go
While Bohm was productive late in the season and played a good first base after the trade deadline, the Phillies could benefit from parting ways with the right-handed batter in free agency. He was an above-average hitter with a 101 OPS+ in his first seven years with Philadelphia, but his spot in the batting order and at the corner could use an upgrade. Bryce Harper is set to return to first in 2027, so third base could be open for prospect Aidan Miller if he can continue to stay healthy — unless the Phillies need him at shortstop, a possibility after president of baseball operations Dave Dombrowski said Trea Turner’s future at the position is at risk if he doesn’t play better defense. The infield could have some moving parts, so the club should probably only lock in a corner-only defender if he’s a serious offensive improvement.
Bailey Digh — Staff Writer: Go
Bohm is what he is – a serviceable, everyday big league player. The Phillies need more than that, from multiple spots, to be better in 2027. It’s time for change, for both the player and the organization. I do wonder, though: Would Bohm be an attractive player for the Phillies to pursue this winter if he had played his first seven years with another club?
Nathan Ackerman — Staff Writer: Go
There will be some mild clamoring for the Phillies to keep Bohm because of his solid last two months (.305/.383/.424) and 4-for-12 (with a double and a homer) postseason. It should instead be seen as a nice way to end a long Phillies career. The Phillies need better production in the cleanup (or near-cleanup) spot of the lineup, and a longer track record suggests that they’d most likely find it elsewhere.


berksbaseball
October 20, 2026 at 2:47 pm
Exactly WHO on the remaining roster is going to drive in 88 runs and hit in the clutch?
Frank James Winter
October 24, 2026 at 7:11 pm
Exactly, but no one seems to recognize it.
Fleming Hill
October 20, 2026 at 8:21 pm
More clutch than anyone else . When a hit is needed, I want Bohm or Stott up!
This shouldn’t be a discussion as the front office once again as f’d up!
Frank James Winter
October 24, 2026 at 7:13 pm
They should either try and sign him for a reasonable contract maybe 4 year at 50mil. or offer him a QO but that will be steep at 23.1mil.
Tom Dockery
October 21, 2026 at 12:55 pm
I want Bohm in the pinstripes next season,just not for the Yankees.
He would hit liner after liner into the Jeffrey Maier seats in right.
Cashman was extended today.He may just sign Bohm.
JeffW
October 21, 2026 at 2:38 pm
The question is, if they don’t keep him who would they get? All those who say GO, better think about that. By the way I think he played just fine at 1st base.
Money
October 24, 2026 at 9:17 am
He is much better at 3b than he used to be but not great. You can rule out first base that’s Harpers position now. Bohm’s a Scott Boras client and he will command a ton of dough. Hopefully sign Sosa as a backup and hope the kid Miller is ready. Like Bohm, but can’t bring back the same team and hope for a better result.