News

Stay or Go: Has longest-tenured Phillies reliever José Alvarado pitched his last game with team?

José Alvarado will be a free agent. (Logan Gehman/Phillies Nation)

Following a rocky 2025 season, the Phillies picked up left-hander José Alvarado‘s club option for 2026. He had started last year on a strong note, displaying rediscovered velocity and proving to be a reliable late-game reliever in a razor-thin bullpen.

Then, he was suspended for 80 games on May 18 after testing positive for a performance-enhancing drug. He returned in August, but he did not have the same sharpness. He eventually finished the season on the injured list; he was not eligible for postseason play.

Still, the Phillies decided to retain Alvarado at a price of $9 million. If he had performed anywhere near his most dominant, that would have been a bargain. But this season, Alvarado turned in the worst statistical performance of his career with a 5.68 ERA in 68 games. He had a stretch late in the year in which he threw the ball quite well, but he followed it up with a pair of three-run outings to finish out the regular season. Alvarado did not appear in the Phillies’ three-game Wild Card Series loss.

Now, Alvarado is set to become a free agent, and Philadelphia will have to make a decision. Could the team help him regain that elite form that he showed at times? Or should the organization let its longest-tenured reliever, who appeared in 23 playoff games from 2022 to 2024, walk in favor of a potential upgrade from the left side?

Here’s part three of Phillies Nation’s Stay or Go series. Vote in our poll below the article.

Past editions:

Destiny Lugardo — Site Director: Go

A lack of pitching depth led the Phillies to picking up Alvarado’s $9 million 2026 club option. He will leave with a complicated legacy. One of the best relievers in the sport in 2022 and 2023, Alvarado has not been the same guy for years. He was booed walking to the mound from the bullpen and off the mound in his final appearance in a Phillies uniform on Sept. 26. But I’ll never forget when Alvarado, after Game 1 of the 2022 NLDS in Atlanta, uttered the famous words, “Strike one, strike two, good luck.”

Ty Daubert — Editorial Director: Go

The Phillies have already brought back Tim Mayza as a solid left-handed option for a variety of situations. Next, they should look elsewhere for a high-leverage lefty. Alvarado was not effective enough this season to show that he can be a go-to piece near the end of games moving forward, and that’s what the Phillies need in front of closer Jhoan Duran. After leading Philadelphia in appearances this year, Alvarado will likely be pitching somewhere else in 2027.

Bailey Digh — Staff Writer: Go

Like with Alec Bohm, it feels like change for both the player and organization makes the most sense here. Alvarado has not been his best for a while now. He is no longer a trustworthy, high-leverage reliever, which the Phillies need. The bullpen needs to be rebuilt this winter, especially from the left side. It’s time for the Phillies to try something new there.

Nathan Ackerman — Staff Writer: Go 

Alvarado had some great moments with the Phillies. (Is your heart still racing from the NLCS Game 1 save in San Diego?) He also had some, well, not-as-great ones. None stand out quite like the Yordan Álvarez blast in Game 6 of the 2022 World Series, but a disproportionate number happened in the last couple years, particularly after Alvarado’s 2025 suspension. The Phillies need a bullpen overhaul; the departure of Dave Dombrowski’s first addition as a Phillie is the place to start.

Poll
José Alvarado: Stay or Go? *

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2026
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top