Phillies Nation


Is Joe Girardi worried about Bryce Harper’s reaction if J.T. Realmuto leaves?

Bryce Harper has been vocal about hoping the Phillies re-sign J.T. Realmuto. (Frank Jansky/Icon Sportswire)

When Bryce Harper was introduced as a Philadelphia Phillie in March of 2019, he referred to his new teammate J.T. Realmuto as “his favorite player” in baseball. When you consider that Harper said in his final media availability of the 2020 season that “Realmuto needs to be our catcher next year, plain and simple,” it feels safe to say that preference still stands.

So what happens if the Phillies don’t ulimately retain Realmuto?

Set aside, for a second, any debates about whether the Phillies can, should or will re-sign Realmuto this winter. Let’s say for a second that someone other than Realmuto is starting at catcher for the Phillies on opening day 2021. Is Joe Girardi worried that Harper will be discontent when he returns for his third season in Philadelphia?

“You know, I think you always worry about how players are going to handle things when things maybe don’t go exactly the way they want or they think they should go,” Girardi admitted. “Obviously, I’ll sit down and have discussions with him, and I’m sure Dave [Dombrowski] will probably have discussions with Bryce about ‘Look, we want to win just as badly as you do, trust us. And we’re going to do everything we can to bring a championship to Philadelphia. Sometimes, things don’t go exactly the way you want, but you gotta trust us.’ You gotta trust Dave and what Dave is going to do.”

The New York Mets, who many believed would sign Realmuto at the outset of the offseason, ultimately bowed out early in the sweepstakes, instead signing James McCann to a four-year/$40 million deal over the weekend. Certainly, the team expected to spend the most money this offseason not ending up as a major player for Realmuto increases the chances that his asking price ultimately comes down to an area that the Phillies are comfortable with.

Make no mistake, though, it will burn in a lot of senses for the Phillies if Realmuto walks away. He’s been arguably the most complete player on the team over the past two seasons, and even with him, the Phillies weren’t able to reach the postseason or post a winning record. Should he depart in free agency, you’ll be left to wonder if the Phillies aren’t more likely to finish in last place in a crowded National League East in 2021 than in first.

The relationship between Harper and Realmuto, though, seemingly extends beyond just being teammates. The two and their wives got dinner in Las Vegas, Harper’s hometown, on Oct. 25. Perhaps it began as just being teammates, but now the two are friends, and Girardi can relate to disappointment in potentially losing one of your favorite teammates.

“There’s friendships that sometimes play a role in that, and I get that. I’ve been with teammates that I loved being a teammate with and the next year they’re not there and it’s a little bit difficult. But you form new relationships and you get involved in the season and then it just kind of becomes normal again. But, in a time where you aren’t extremely busy, I think you probably think about it a lot more.”

Would Harper hide his discontent when he arrives at spring training (assuming there is spring training) if Realmuto signs elsewhere this offseason? Maybe not, but then it will be a story for a few days, and ultimately he’ll still be tasked with playing right field for the Phillies in 2021.

Should Realmuto leave, it’s a very real possibility that the Phillies don’t reach the postseason in any of Harper’s first three seasons with the team. (That possibility also exists, if Realmuto returns, for the record.) For that to happen, even as he’s been excellent, would be a massive disappointment. But then a potentially historic class of free agent shortstops will be looming, and if the world is back to normal, the Phillies may be more inclined to spend next winter. Perhaps spending big money on Francisco Lindor or Carlos Correa next offseason would ultimately prove to be a better way to maximize Harper’s time with the team, even if such a scenario would create more frustration in the short term.

The truth is, there’s not a ton Harper could do if he was upset about the trajectory of the team. He has 11 seasons remaining on his contract, and he insisted on not having an opt out in his contract so his future (and that of his family) was set in stone. From a stability standpoint, that makes sense. However, he can’t hold the Phillies feet to the fire the way he maybe could have if he had the possibility of opting out after the fourth or fifth season of his deal. For better or for worse, Harper is going to be here.


  1. Phillies Offseason Primer: Payroll, Free Agents And Trades
  2. The Phillies’ Path To Signing J.T. Realmuto Becomes Easier With Deal Between McCann, Mets
  3. What Will Matt Klentak’s Role Be Under Dave Dombrowski?
  4. All-Time Phillies Great Dick Allen Dies At 78
  5. Dave Dombrowski Speaks About The Possibility of Re-Signing J.T. Realmuto
  6. Multiple Insiders Confirm Phillies Did Talk Zack Wheeler Trade With Other Teams
  7. Dave Dombrowski Praises First-Round Pick Mick Abel In Introductory Press Conference
  8. How The Phillies Went From ‘Sleeping Giants’ To Disappointing In The Blink Of An Eye
  9. Girardi: ‘There Are 30 Teams That Would Love To Have J.T., And We’re At The Top Of The List
  10. 6 Phillies Appear On 2021 Hall Of Fame Ballot


  1. Steve Dwyer

    December 15, 2020 at 2:31 am

    TRADE SEGURA with so many middle infielders who all play shortstop in the pipeline he is expendable. There is 15 million towards Realmuto’s 25 million PLUS DEAL to resign. Say 5 years 25+ per year. USE the KIDS at Rookie money where you can as in Moniak LEFT Muzziotti CENTER Maton 2nd BASE even Gamboa at Shortstop WHY NOT?

    • Philly For Life

      December 15, 2020 at 8:28 am

      That’s about a 60 win season line-up you propose…

  2. Philly For Life

    December 15, 2020 at 8:31 am

    I could care less about Harper’s feelings… He’s being paid $30 million a year to perform no matter who plays catcher of honestly any other position…

    • Keg

      December 15, 2020 at 9:22 am

      I agree with your assessment of that lineup. However, Harper came here because we promised him a chance to win. JT gives us the best chance to do that.

  3. Thomas Gaitens

    December 15, 2020 at 2:49 pm

    We have a shipwreck to deal with…our last GM screwed the nanny with the Realmuto trade. We had our tandem catcher with Knapp, with Alfaro, not great–but workable. We had our two back end starters in Sixto Sanchez and Spencer Howard. If we do not resign Realmuto now, it was a horrific trade which netted us nothing! A Ferguson Jenkins like trade.
    IF we do not resign Realmuto, this will turn out in Phillies history as having been the 5-1 Von Hayes Trade at best and Ferguson Jenkins trade at worst..not good either way. So how do you sign him…

    First, realize this and build around him. ditch unproductive $$. Segura!

    Second, we need to take our lumps with the Herrera contract and play him in Left and move Cutch to DH…yes, there will be a DH in the NL! This actually frees up salary that had been dead for use. IF there is no DH, then you have to use Herrera as a fourth outfielder.

    Third, Yes, I would trade Segura, if there were real takers,(salary dump for relivers or depth in system) and utilize Kingery as everyday 2nd.
    We drafted a Stott to be the future at SS, well that is after the All-Star game or opening day 2022…so bring in a low cost good fielding option of Galvis—bring him back on a 1 or 2 year deal. He can serve as the super infield sub for 2022.
    Bohm, Hoskins round out the infield. Sign Miller as the back up and you still have the combo Hasely and Quinn as CF options…along with Herrera depending.
    Finally, signing a LH pitcher to fill the 4th/5th spot along with Howard is key IMHO. Hamels would be a solid choice…he would team up with Harper and Realmuto to be a huge Fan-favorite marketing machine.

    Utilizing Herrera salary is key to this…dumping Segura is huge…these two moves help to free up that 20+M.

Leave a Reply

Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Phillies Nation has been bringing Phillies fans together since 2004 with non-stop news, analysis, trade rumors, trips, t-shirts, and other fun stuff!

Browse the Archives

Browse by Category

Copyright Phillies Nation, LLC 2004-2021
Not Affiliated with Major League Baseball or the Philadelphia Phillies

To Top